Besides Young and Stroud, no other QB has me sold they would be a clear upgrade over PJ.

[Skack25]

22 minutes ago, Pakmeng said:

My thoughts exactly but Hooker intrigues me. Not at a really high pick though.

Yea I mean, if we can get Hooker late second - third, I would be on board.

[shaq]

Stroud is who I want, great release and accuracy. Sign me up all day for that kid.

[CarolinaRideorDie]

People on here really think PJ is the answer? Then why the hell didn't we just start him week one and decided to trade assets for Mayfield and Darnold? Watch PJ make one incomplete pass this week and the Huddle will ask for him to be benched! lol 

[grimesgoat]

PJ walker has started 5 games in the NFL.  Here are his numbers in those starts:

91-137 66% 979 yds. 5 TDs, 4 Ints, 5 Sks, 3-2 record.

Here are the numbers for a certain all-everything QB in his first 5 games in the NFL (pie for the first to name him):

93-169 55% 1,142 yds., 3 Tds 12 Ints, 15 sks, 1-4 record.

The point is not to suggest these two are destined for the same things (as some will surely assume right away).  The point is that 5 games in is a little early to decide whether someone sucks and will always suck. The second guy improved significantly over the next several years. Chances are PJ isn't a long-term solution, but good lord we're 5 games in.  There is a learning curve in this league.

 

[saX man]

14 minutes ago, grimesgoat said:

PJ walker has started 5 games in the NFL.  Here are his numbers in those starts:

91-137 66% 979 yds. 5 TDs, 4 Ints, 5 Sks, 3-2 record.

Here are the numbers for a certain all-everything QB in his first 5 games in the NFL (pie for the first to name him):

93-169 55% 1,142 yds., 3 Tds 12 Ints, 15 sks, 1-4 record.

The point is not to suggest these two are destined for the same things (as some will surely assume right away).  The point is that 5 games in is a little early to decide whether someone sucks and will always suck. The second guy improved significantly over the next several years. Chances are PJ isn't a long-term solution, but good lord we're 5 games in.  There is a learning curve in this league.

 

I wouldn't say we'd be judging him too soon--he's a 5 year vet UDFA with a sub 57% completion rate to speak to in college and under 58% for his NFL career so far.  He's just not the answer.   

[grimesgoat]

10 minutes ago, saX man said:

I wouldn't say we'd be judging him too soon--he's a 5 year vet UDFA with a sub 57% completion rate to speak to in college and under 58% for his NFL career so far.  He's just not the answer.   

I agree he's probably not the answer.  And his college career is sub-par.  But when he starts, he's not too bad.  He's getting better - we should give him the rest of the season.  I think he is a solid tank commander.

 

[BrianS]

PJ Walker is the answer only if the question is "Who was the Panthers last full time starter before <insert long term answer here>?"

[bobcat91]

If Stroud is not available, I'm iffy on Young. He is small and injury prone. I'd go will Anderson who is the best player in the draft. 

[UpstatePantherfan]

9 minutes ago, bobcat91 said:

If Stroud is not available, I'm iffy on Young. He is small and injury prone. I'd go will Anderson who is the best player in the draft. 

I dunno, I’m just not feeling defense this draft. Don’t get me wrong, I think he will be a great player but I just think our D is pretty stacked already so you have to start wondering about the whole “law of diminishing returns things.” Does adding another stout D player to what is already a strong D really move the needle for this team as a whole?!

Personally im starting to get hyped about the possibility of drafting Quentin Johnston in the first round, him paired up with DJ Moore as our no 1/no 2 would almost be like a video game. He is a 6’4 WR that runs a 4.4 and knows how to run routes. 
 

 

[Jay Roosevelt]

People around here are so desperate they really think Wilks/Walker is the long-term answer.

It's better than Rhule, but let's not kid ourselves here. 

[bga71]

I would like to see Corral next season with a year of practice and film study.  He may be the guy.

[Move the Panthers to Raleigh]

Gotdamn the bar is so fuging low for some people

[Basbear]

I dont like any of the QBs from this class (some levis love tho) nor Pj as the future starter. Hell give Corral a real chance if these are the options......feel like another Daniel Jones type of year....

[Shocker]

If Matt Corral was Sam Howell I would definitely consider giving him a shot but he isn’t.  
 

If we are a position to take a QB we will…no question 

I see Levis as a bust right now though.  Hooker is playing elite right now but is old with very overrated athleticism.  We go down the line from there

Edited November 1, 2022 by Shocker