Jump to content

  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Looking at Success or Failure of top 10 to 12 QBs since 2000

Hoenheim

By Hoenheim,
in Carolina Panthers

 Share

Recommended Posts

Hoenheim Grand Master

Hoenheim

Posted
  • Author
Posted
4 minutes ago, Shotgun said:

Lawrence has had sustained success? How many winning seasons has he had?

 

Just now, Hoenheim said:

In fact reclassifiying the good and greats into 1 "good" category makes it more concise and less prone to mockery from the peanut gallery 😀 

23 busts 

5 average QBs

18 good QBs

23 busts vs 23 avg or good QBs 

#1 QB 63% chance of being "non bust"

 

  • Beer 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
frankw Grand Master

frankw

Posted
Posted (edited)

2021 draft is still quite recent I would not even call Lawrence a great success just yet and even Lance and Wilson still have time albeit not that much. Fields has shown legit potential but he needs to take several steps in this upcoming season or he's teetering on the edge.

Overall the odds aren't as bad as you'd think based on this list. But they also aren't as good as some people are making it out to be rationalizing downplaying very real concerns for the top 2 QB's in this years draft. Stroud or Young may not even end up being the best.

Edited by frankw
  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Hoenheim Grand Master

Hoenheim

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I'd make a disclaimer or change the original post into just good and not good vs great but I can't.  That was my mistake now everyone's just going to hyper focus on the wrong thing, the good vs great qbs isn't my point.  

My point is the busts vs non busts  especially as it relates to first QB taken.  The biggest take away is #1 QB selected had about 63% of not being a bust. That seems to imply taking QB first overall is less of a crapshoot then some people make it out to be and might assuage some people's fears of it not working out.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
shaq Mentor

shaq

Posted
Posted
14 minutes ago, Hoenheim said:

I'd make a disclaimer or change the original post into just good and not good vs great but I can't.  That was my mistake now everyone's just going to hyper focus on the wrong thing, the good vs great qbs isn't my point.  

My point is the busts vs non busts  especially as it relates to first QB taken.  The biggest take away is #1 QB selected had about 63% of not being a bust. That seems to imply taking QB first overall is less of a crapshoot then some people make it out to be and might assuage some people's fears of it not working out.

 

Learning experience, don’t worry about it  I see your point. Just can’t confuse people with the subjective,  non statistically based differential arguments you made between good and great.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
pantherj Grand Master

pantherj

Posted
Posted
26 minutes ago, Hoenheim said:

In fact reclassifiying the good and greats into 1 "good" category makes it more concise and less prone to mockery from the peanut gallery 😀 

23 busts 

5 average QBs

18 good QBs

23 busts vs 23 avg or good QBs 

#1 QB 63% chance of being "non bust"

And 5.57% the QB is great.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
CPantherKing Grand Master

CPantherKing

Posted
Posted

You are better off avoiding a 1st round QB unless they are a consensus pedigree 5 star QB who has had consistent success in college over 4 years. You will miss a lot more than you hit and waste the draft capital needed to build a championship roster.

My standard for a top 10 pick QB is instant starter, playoff winner, consistent SB contender, and min 10 year career. Otherwise, you are just as well off drafting the 1st round QB who falls out of the 1st round.

85% of QBs who are given a franchise QB opportunity make it to the playoffs. Doesn't matter what round. 1st round picks actually get to the playoffs 80% of the time. 6th round to undrafted QBs who are given the franchise QB opportunity get to the playoffs 90% of the time. The top 10 QBs you listed who are given a franchise QB opportunity get to the playoffs 70% of the time.

My standard of success for QBs related to their draft position is not who gets drafted or who gets a franchise QB opportunity. I want to know what QBs successfully lead their draft team for multiple years. Level 1 success is getting the team to the playoffs. Level 2 success is winning with their team in the playoffs. Level 3 success is getting their team to a championship. Level 4 success is winning a championship and getting to the SB with their drafted team. Level 5 success is winning the SB with their team. Break each level of success down by round. You will be surprised how overrated 1st round QBs have been and continue to be.

1st round QBs who have failed their draft position and redeemed themselves with another team at the SB level happen every decade. Jim Plunkett/Doug Williams from the 70s. Steve Young from the 80s. Trent Dilfer from the 90s. Matthew Stafford from the 2000s. There will be one of the many failed 1st round QBs from the 2010s that will add themselves to this list (Panthers fans have been hoping to find this rare failure through their lineup of Bridgewater, Darnold, and Mayfield). My money is on Lamar Jackson achieving this once in a decade feat.

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Obeg Contributor

Obeg

Posted
Posted

I applaud the effort to illustrate the obvious issue we face. You certainly messed up with the ratings.  Probably been better off just ranking as "QB who signed (or will sign) next contract with drafting team as the starter."

Most likely (based on past performance) our pick this year will NOT turn out to be a "franchise QB".  That is just the fact.  

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
ForJimmy Grand Master

ForJimmy

Posted
Posted

I think coaching staff can have a lot to do with it. Lawrence with Meyer vs Pederson. Some elite ones can win in spite of their staff (like Cam), but it definitely helps and we have a good one. Our team is also built for a rookie QB right now. I think several of them are capable of finding success in Carolina.

  • Pie 4
  • Beer 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • coffee
      If you need some ‘chills’ to start your Friday….

      By coffee · Posted

      In January 2014, I posted this on another forum.  Seems like it fits again:   Do you remember cheering for the rain? Trying to sleep after “The no-call”? Do you know who needs to "Ice up, son"?   Remember pleading for .500? Thinking there’s no catching the Saints? Punting to Buffalo and knowing how it was going to end?   Do you remember how you felt about Kalil’s ad? Or the fan’s follow up? Gruden’s interview with Cam?   Do you remember Clausen being the steal of the draft? Will you ever forgive Mel Kiper?   Did you cry as Jake said his goodbyes? Do you remember the game that cost Gruden his job?   As fans chant “Luuuuuuke,” do you still hear “Moooose”? … “Hoooove”?   Do you recall changing the diaper? Paddling the boat? Being happy just hearing the name Smoot?   Do you recall the day when it hurt to say “Keep pounding,” and you felt you’d lost a close friend?   Did you hunt the net for Bojangle’s commercials? Have you seen a Cajun’s bare butt?   Do you remember the sunken feeling when Smitty was caught from behind and didn’t get up?   Sports Illustrated’s prediction?   Were you angry at Janet for stealing the spotlight? Does “X-Clown” still give you chills? Do you sing the wrong words to “Day-O”? Whenever you hear “He Hate Me,” do you also hear Rosinski finishing the sentence?   Did you like Seifert a little less when he let Walls’ streak of games-with-a-reception end? But nothing compared to letting Steve go, right? Do you remember that invincible feeling you had when we won the first game of 2001? Do you recall who our division rivals were?   Do you remember thinking “Just wait ‘til Bazooka’s healthy”? How about that weird grin you got watching Kevin Greene fire up the D? Or being undefeated at Ericsson?   If your answer is “no,” we happily welcome you as a new fan of our beloved team. Trust me, we’ll be happy to explain all of these and more to catch you up. For the rest of you, it’s been entirely too long since we were alive after week 17. But every question that you answered “yes” to makes this all the sweeter. Welcome to the playoffs.
    • PantherChris
      Kotkaniemi Available

      By PantherChris · Posted

      Future considerations......     DUE to several high dollar players spending time on IR the canes have    37M in trade deadline cap space.....    
    • strato
      I am giving away two tickets tomorrow FOR FREE

      By strato · Posted

      My 20 year old hoodie is still holding together.    PS if you want to get technical, any cable or streaming sub, even watching the network broadcasts, is supporting him. 
×
×
  • Create New...