Coaches hot seat rating

[LinvilleGorge]

32 minutes ago, TheCasillas said:

Raiders can't afford to fire McDaniels. I mean that literally. His contract is too much, from my understanding the Raiders financially can't fire him until the 24-25 season. 

also, Shanahan should be much higher on that list than he is. Saleh too.


lastly, based on some of the Huddle ... Reich should be at the top of the list for not winning a game this preseason.

Shanahan? The Niners went 13-4 last year and have winning records in three of the last four seasons. Shanahan's seat is ice cold.

[Mr. Scot]

5 minutes ago, CRA said:

Doug Pederson at 6% and ahead of some of those guys seems really weird 

Probably comes with being coach of the Jaguars...

[UnluckyforSome]

Barring something unexpected, like winning the East, Rivera is gone after this season. New ownership, possible new branding of the team, out with all the old, and add in the missed opportunities, lowered expectations and having a capable interim coach, or replacement coach on staff already, and it's pretty clear cut.

[LinvilleGorge]

3 minutes ago, UnluckyforSome said:

Barring something unexpected, like winning the East, Rivera is gone after this season. New ownership, possible new branding of the team, out with all the old, and add in the missed opportunities, lowered expectations and having a capable interim coach, or replacement coach on staff already, and it's pretty clear cut.

He probably doesn't have to win the division but I do think it's probably playoffs or bust for him.

[NYPantherFan]

I'm honestly surprised that the new Cardinals HC isn't at the top of this list already. I feel like they brought him in knowing full well they will replace him and bring in an offensive mind when they have their choice of QB next draft. 

[Jackie Lee]

They consider this guys safe? He might get canned by week 5 

 

[TheCasillas]

1 hour ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Shanahan? The Niners went 13-4 last year and have winning records in three of the last four seasons. Shanahan's seat is ice cold.

look at his season records prior... he has had 3 winning seasons and 3 losing seasons. He has lost the core of his coaching staff and regressed as those coaches have left. He blundered the Trey Lance situation, and it has been reported that him and john lynch do not see eye to eye. If 49ers do not have a winning season this year.... i am willing to bet my avatar that Kyle or John are gone in SF.... 

[TheCasillas]

13 minutes ago, Jackie Lee said:

They consider this guys safe? He might get canned by week 5 

 

yeah the dude is weird as fug.... but execs that have worked with him said he is the genius type not a people type. I was ripping the guy to shreds before i did some background research on him. 

I dont think he is a good HC but as a coordinator and schemer, apparently he is one of the best on defense.

Edited September 3, 2023 by TheCasillas

[ickmule]

2 hours ago, TheCasillas said:

astly, based on some of the Huddle ... Reich should be at the top of the list for not winning a game this preseason.

Give it time. Many in here will have him at the top of the list. I will predict that he won’t make it to mid season before some are screaming. 

Edited September 3, 2023 by ickmule

[tukafan21]

12 seasons as a HC, only had a winning record 3 times, and has won 2 COY awards.

It really doesn't make sense how someone has cobbled together that kind of career in an age where most coaches can't go more than 2 seasons of losing records without getting fired.

But it all goes back to my problem with him while he was here, he's a great Monday to Saturday coach, his players all love him and love to play for him, but he's a beyond terrible gamely coach who realistically would have never risen above being a DC.

Edited September 3, 2023 by tukafan21

[Sgt Schultz]

I don't have a problem with Rivera, but you have to realize what he is and what he provides.  If you screw yourself and hire a disaster as a HC who makes a clusterfug out of your team and organization, Rivera is one of the guys you call to stop the ship from sinking.  The revolt among the players will come to an end, the team will focus on football, and controversy will subside.  They will build cohesion.

Think Denver after they waited too long to fire McDaniels (who should have been fired within 30 days of his hiring, before ever stepping foot on the field).  Hell, think us after The Process was canned.  Wilks is of that same ilk.

But, they are never going to come up with some brilliant game plan, make some incredible adjustment within a game, call that mind-blowing play at a critical time, and steal a win from the jaws of certain defeat.

That's what you get with Rivera, Wilks, or Fox: stability.  And for some organizations, that is a dramatic improvement.  I'd say DC has been one of them.

As long as organizations screw themselves with disastrous head coaching hires they have to recover from, the Riveras, Wilks', and Foxes will have jobs.  And I don't think organizations will screw themselves any less in the next 10 years than they have in the last 50.

[Mr. Scot]

2 hours ago, Jackie Lee said:

They consider this guys safe? He might get canned by week 5 

 

I don't think they included any of the new head coaches.

[MHS831]

7 hours ago, mrcompletely11 said:

Or he kinda sucks as a head coach

Agree-Ron ran Cam Newton into the ground to save his job.  He was not a good coach.  We now have a good coach--  Ron would have been here 3 years tops had we not drafted Cam.

 

[Panthercougar68]

7 hours ago, ladypanther said:

Read the line at the bottom of the pic....is performance based only.

Was at work all day and didn’t read the article lol