Jon Beason: Would we have been better off?

[TheRumGone]

i kinda agree with the op. You did get a great player but you already decent player but the upgrade on the offensive line would have been great. I know everyone love keek and all but this is something serious to consider.

Keek takes over games, those two players would not.

[Ruff]

This is actually the worst thread I've ever seen on the huddle.

[CarolinaCoolin]

This is under the assumption Beason would still remain healthy. The reason luke played mlb is because Beason got hurt. So if we didn't have luke Beason still goes down and our defense doesn't get to the top 10 by the end of the season. Then we come in this year with a questionable Beason and there's no way our defense plays as good to get us to 12-4. Ultimately the right move was made. Reif would have been a reach at 9.

[csx]

Again....argue that we should have taken Glenn over Silatolu. Glenn is significantly better than Reiff and we could have had them both.

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

i mean imagine if someone made a thread about some scenario where we could have gotten better value out of the pick spent on steve smith after the 2005 season

 

who gives a poo.  it's similar to the dummies who think cam's skill set, production, and potential grows on trees.  what kuechly brings is so ludicrously rare and valuable that the question is asinine and it doesn't matter what we spent to get him.

[Mvp2014]

All personal achievements for Keuchly and his family. I'm happy for him but doesn't exactly mean SBs for the panthers organization. We're in a perpetual rebuilding mode and contracts(including Keuchly's) is coming up. We could be going into this off season in search of only a franchise WR and some secondary help. Now we need a franchise LT, WR, and secondary. That's it very hard to get in one off season with no money and drafting bottom of the draft.

 

I see what you are saying but I would rather look at our future than this upcoming year.  Keek presents more value than any one tackle, receiver, db..  He makes everyone on the D better  

[pstall]

Bias is like bad breathe. Everybody knows but the offender.

Sent from my SPH-L710 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[carpanfan96]

This is actually the worst thread I've ever seen on the huddle.

 

 

Yes it is. I don't even think it's a contest either and I've seen some horrible threads in the 9 years I've been on here. 

[Mojo]

Not trying to disrespect your intelligence, but are you serious ? I'm really trying to wrap my head around why you'd do this to yourself.

[mav1234]

so we could either have a decent middle linebacker with a serious history of injuries and a decent lineman or the best defensive player in the league.  this is a tough one

[SteveSmithTD89]

If you wanted to see a highlight reel of just tackles a yard or two past the line of scrimmage I can give you a 35 minute video of Luke.  The two aren't in the same league.  Its not even close.

[Pox 08]

Yes...................who needs the DPOY?  When we could have had an average tackle.

[FattyFatFat]

Wish we would've gotten a fourth for beason knowing what we know now. Howeva!

[top dawg]

Evengelion, I can appreciate your wanting to foster interesting discussion, but you had to know that this would end badly.