Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Question: Do you consider RIvera top tier HC?


Jmac

Recommended Posts

At this juncture in his tenure, do you feel that he has developed into a upper tier coach? He still seems to stick with older vets longer then he should to a fault. Other wise, he has build a tough and resilient team. Over coming the loss of key players is tough to do for any coach. Taking his body of work so far, what do you think?

 

..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No.

1. Clock management is always an issue.

2. While the TV guys are talking about Cam's size and ability as a runner, on a 4th and 1 play in the first half they decide to try to loft one to Olsen. I'll never be convinced Mike Shula is anything better than a QB coach and for Rivera to give him full reign of the offense is ludicrous.

3. Some may want to hang all personnel issues on Gettlemen, but he's not doing it alone. If there's anyone here who believes Ron Rivera simply takes whatever players Gettleman gets him, you're sadly misinformed. And the Carolina Panthers could be an elite football team if they'd ever decide to develop rookies, grab the occasional marquee free agent or look beyond their own roster to fill the obvious gaps.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No.

1. Clock management is always an issue.

2. While the TV guys are talking about Cam's size and ability as a runner, on a 4th and 1 play in the first half they decide to try to loft one to Olsen. I'll never be convinced Mike Shula is anything better than a QB coach and for Rivera to give him full reign of the offense is ludicrous.

3. Some may want to hang all personnel issues on Gettlemen, but he's not doing it alone. If there's anyone here who believes Ron Rivera simply takes whatever players Gettleman gets him, you're sadly misinformed. And the Carolina Panthers could be an elite football team if they'd ever decide to develop rookies, grab the occasional marquee free agent or look beyond their own roster to fill the obvious gaps.

Olsen was wide open on that play, largely because they expected Cam to run. A better throw nets the first and even a TD.

To the question, Rivera does some things exceptionally well (culture, defense) and in very average in other areas (clock management).  If top-tier means Top 10, he probably sneaks in, but I do think he's good enough to win an SB if the chips fall correctly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2. While the TV guys are talking about Cam's size and ability as a runner, on a 4th and 1 play in the first half they decide to try to loft one to Olsen. I'll never be convinced Mike Shula is anything better than a QB coach and for Rivera to give him full reign of the offense is ludicrous.

Look I love Cam, but that's on him.  The play call set Cam up for success.  You either run for the easy first down or hit Olsen for a chunk gain.  The play call was good, Cam's decision was good, the throw/execution wasn't.  

 

If Olsen scores or Cam gets the first we're not talking about the play call today.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 so star, kk, Benjamin, norman, bene, boston, turner, norwell, brown, funchess is not considered developing young talent? Correct me, but I thought Carolina has one of the youngest rosters in the NFL

Could not have said it Any better.  Don't Forget Shaq and though they are not with us anymore how about Melvin White. 

We stuck with the Vets a little too long in 2014, got it, but I don't feel that is the norm.

Because you have 30 seconds and two time outs doesn't necessarily mean push your luck.  We were down 10-7 in a tightly contested game.  We just got the ball back after screwing up a good opportunity to tie the game.  I could see where we might press to make things up and instead of getting into field goal range we throw a Pick 6 and the whole game changes.

While we may have wanted us to do that.  I respect and understand Rivera's decision.   It is so simple for us to bitch and moan about clock management but Rivera gets paid to make these decision.   He is 5-0.  Seems most of his decisions pay off.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's hard to say yes when you see Roman Harper out there covering Graham and/or getting burnt often.

I think it could be close, but I still think he gets outcoached often, especially because of how we let teams come back quite often.  We never quite get a clean dominating win that often.  Until I see Rivera able to outcoach other coaches more, I'm so sure.  But he's definitely been much better this year.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As a motivator, you can't deny the job he has done considering the team has been going through a prolonged rebuilding phase.

But as a tactician, he has a very long way to go. The only redeeming factor here is that he recognizes his mistakes in game management and will adjust accordingly, but if the only adjustment is "going for it more on 4th and short" and not making the tough decisions like admitting Mike Shula may not be the right guy for the offense, then he's never going to be much better than just a master motivator, which at least counts for something.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I mean, this year we should've easily been a playoff team in my opinion. We should have easily had two or three more wins--at least one--had not Bryce crapped the bed. But let's be serious about human nature and what we know about our FO. I wouldn't bet the farm that Bryce will be anything but the defacto starter in 2026, because (inconsistent though it was) we have exceeded expectations this year, and some in the FO probably believe, rightly or wrongly, that Bryce is at the center of that. You know, piece of bread seems like a meal if all you've had is a cracker. That being said, Bryce has shown plenty of inconsistency if not a downright pattern of flaws. He's a third year QB, and some, if not most, of his metrics aren't pretty. It could be argued that he should be further along (for me it's not really arguable). So, hopefully the decision makers will acquire a couple of plan Bs. I would hate it and love it if we identified "our guy" in the draft, and that it was somehow achievable to acquire him with a couple of high draft picks or even less. But we already pulled the trigger on Bryce with arguably awful results, so that's got to make the decision makers a little skittish to repeat a mistake that should be still fresh on everyone's mind. That being said, I think that it's more likely that we acquire a player like Mac Jones, Malik Willis or Trey Lance in free agency, and also target a day two or day three developmental pick in the draft with some real upside. That pick for would be Drew Allar who should slide to day three (I'm thinking). I think that this is more realistic than them releasing Bryce from his starter's role from the get-go, or someone just flat out playing themselves definitely into the starter's role by the time the season begins.  Now, again, if we can find "our guy" that changes the narrative and is expected to be the starter from day one, I'd be excited, if not downright ecstatic, but I don't think that's a realistic expectation.  Getting back to the team in general, If we don't make some improvements, including QB, I wouldn't bet that we'd necessarily be a playoff team next year, because, the rest of the NFCS is likely to improve next year. I don't expect that teams in our division will be necessarily able to "backdoor" themselves into the playoffs next season. So we're going to have to hit on at least a couple of picks, get healthy along the line, and fundamentally change the way we're calling plays because lightning probably isn't striking twice. I'm hoping that we'll have a real breakthrough season by 2028, because this season and next season aren't likely to be it because removing ball-and-chains ain't easy unless you got the key, and It's still gonna take some time to find it.
    • Necas is not the missing piece here.
    • There was also a ridiculous amount of stock put into the S2 test and Bryce's results were off the chart and Stroud's private results were "leaked" and he was called an imbecile, one of the nicer thing said about him. The caveat though was that you could practice for the S2 and Bryce had been taking it for a long time. The hype machine was fueled and Tepper along with Fitts & co bought it hook line and sinker. 
×
×
  • Create New...