Carolina Definitely Chose the Wrong QB

[OldhamA]

On 1/18/2024 at 3:27 PM, jayboogieman said:

Yeah, the trade was a huge mistake and cost way too much. As for Young being peaked, eh, he can add muscle and get stronger. He can also work on his passing and footwork to improve them. Young can't do squat about his height though. He's not going to get taller.

I'm not willing to call him a bust yet though. Let's see what happens after he has an NFL offseason strength and conditioning program and hopefully at least an average NFL Oline playing to their strengths. Now, if he still looks bad after that, then yeah, I'd say he's a bust.

He went to Alabama - their S&C programme wouldn't look out of place in the NFL. 

[Jackie Lee]

 

[Jackie Lee]

 

[mrcompletely11]

14 minutes ago, Jackie Lee said:

 

fug those nerds

[chbright]

3 minutes ago, Jackie Lee said:

 

Tip of the hat to whoever did that for Houston and the Teppers fell for it

[bandu]

oh boy can you just imagine CJ Stroud wins the OROY this season then next season the #1 overall pick we traded to the Bears wins the OROY as well ...just saying

[RumHam]

On 1/13/2024 at 6:58 PM, The Lobo said:

It’s like every choice we made this off-season was incorrect, outside of Evero and Thelien. 

i don't get why people are still shitting on theilen. Dude showed up.

[RumHam]

On 1/13/2024 at 7:18 PM, uncfan888 said:

One more year and we can pick tepper's wrong choice again

watch him try and trade for justin fields. oh chicago here's another first.

[The Lobo]

25 minutes ago, RumHam said:

i don't get why people are still shitting on theilen. Dude showed up.

He sure did. I don’t blame him for wanting out and trying for a ring. 

[CPantherKing]

I wouldn't have made the trade for a QB, but if the Panthers did I identified the only 2 options.

1. Trade for Lamar Jackson who is the most primed QB per NFL history/data to win his first SB.

2. Draft CJ Stroud if you must take a 1st round rookie.

The best scenario I suggested 2022 offseason was to draft a #1 WR & TE to pair with CMC & Moore, draft 2 on the OL day 3 & load up on 3-4 young QBs to go for the 1999 Rams model moon shot. Garrett Wilson was that WR with true leadership. My top 2 TEs were Jelani Woods & Jake Ferguson. QBs were Purdy, Ridder, Glass & Coan. The OL additions were Zach Tom & Jamaree Salyer. Add Michael Mayer in 2023 (Jack Coan's other college TE)

Purdy, CMC, Wilson, Moore, Ferguson, Mayer, Tom, Christensen, Bozeman, Corbett, Moton would likely be the Panthers starting offense now.

I would have used the draft capital spent on Bryce Young to strengthen the defense.

[Ghostofdelhomme]

If Stroud’s Gilbert Grape S2 is a false negative, is Bryce’s Steven Hawking a false positive?

[mav1234]

20 hours ago, Ghostofdelhomme said:

If Stroud’s Gilbert Grape S2 is a false negative, is Bryce’s Steven Hawking a false positive?

Nah, the kid's just good at video games. Practice makes perfect.

Stroud was too busy practicing on the field.

[Richard Cranium 1]

[Brent Gregory]

As it stands now this is the biggest talent evaluation miss in nfl history. How you could watch and evaluate these 2 qbs and conclude the little guy with no tools was better than the prototype nfl qb with all of them is just mind numbing.