Butler to replace Star?

[t96]

13 minutes ago, RoaringRiot said:

Roll the dice moving Moton to LG and use that money on some offensive weapons for Cam? I wouldn't be upset. 

I don't think the coaching staff sees Moton as a guard, do you?

[WOW!!]

Sign  Norwell and sign a cheaper option to replace Star..

[trueblade]

10 minutes ago, Jon Snow said:

I'm not as down on Matt as everyone here seems to be.  He struggled mightily at times early in the season but he did manage to show progress as the season went on.  He will do for another season until a better option presents itself.  Got to sign Norwell though because he's worth the investment.  I just wish it wasn't Hurney that was going to sign that contact.

Recency bias. Matt got manhandled by Cam Jordan.

[Jon Snow]

Just now, trueblade said:

Recency bias. Matt got manhandled by Cam Jordan.

Meh, it happens to the best of them.   He held his own for the most part.  I look at it this way.  He's hardly played any football in a couple of years due to injury and as this was his first real healthy season I'll cut him some slack.  Next year however he better earn that salary or I'll be screaming to put Moron over there.

[RoaringRiot]

13 minutes ago, thomas96 said:

I don't think the coaching staff sees Moton as a guard, do you?

Not totally sure, but early in the season he was slated at RG. But then Amini got PT over him. So.....?

[thefuzz]

4 minutes ago, Jon Snow said:

We can't run the ball because the scheme is FUBAR.  They can blame the players all they want but our run game is the most predictable and antiquated in the league.  Don't listen to those mouth breathing commentators during the game.  Shula's run game is a joke.

I 100% agree with you, but do you think that Hurney knows enough about the X's and O's to know that's the problem?

This is now a family environment...Ron, Hurn, and Shula all holding hands knowing that they are safe and sound.

Our problem is absolutely scheme, and during the fist half of the season, teams knew that Cam couldn't throw...guessing next year should be much better.

P.S. I think that we are plenty capable at RB with CAP and CMC, maybe grab some depth in the draft late.

[UNCrules2187]

2 hours ago, zacka77ack said:

We actually don't have a ton of depth at the NT/DT/UT position. Short, Butler and Love are the only ones under contract.

Vita Vea probably doesn't make it to 24 but heres a look at Star's replacement if he falls in the draft. The writing is from a Cowboy's needs prospective but it fits for Carolina as well.

 https://www.fanragsports.com/why-vita-vea-makes-sense-for-cowboys-in-1st-round-of-nfl-draft/

If we use another top 2 pick on a DT, I'll blow a gasket. I get that we'd need to replace Star, but I'd rather find a vet to do that. For fug's sake, drafting a DT with our #1 pick this year would mean we'd have spent 3 firsts and a 2nd on DTs within the past 5 years. Time to address other way more pressing positions.

[Camp Fodder]

2 hours ago, stirs said:

Jsut saying that Giants need Oline more than Dline

Gettleman is in charge. DT is the most important position

[Mr. Scot]

4 minutes ago, Camp Fodder said:

Gettleman is in charge. DT is the most important position

Stacked defensive line is actually how the Giants won their last Super Bowl over the Patriots.

[stirs]

29 minutes ago, Camp Fodder said:

Gettleman is in charge. DT is the most important position

Their first pick is probably gonna be a QB.  Not the best situation to stick a guy in there as a rookie to get steamrolled every other down.

A hog mollie is a hog mollie is a hog mollie

[panthers1234]

2 hours ago, Cartel de Carolina said:

You can not drop big money on 2 players at the same position (relative ie DT). 

Pay one and draft the other. 

Bulter is without question going to slide into Star's spot if Star leaves. 

I disagree with this statement. You drop most of the money on the QB, DL, and OL. You can go cheaper on other positions but those are the most impactful positions. 

[TheSpecialJuan]

2 hours ago, Cartel de Carolina said:

You can not drop big money on 2 players at the same position (relative ie DT). 

Pay one and draft the other. 

Bulter is without question going to slide into Star's spot if Star leaves. 

Indeed. Same holds true with Norwell. We have both Kalil's and Trai Turner making big $. Also, Daryl Williams has developed into an excellent RT.

Both Star and Norwell will leave this offseason