Watching replay

[Jackie Lee]

Replay update- Our D-line is trash. Specifically the interior

[TrevorLaurenceTime22]

4 hours ago, Manna said:

Guy was cut from a different cloth. I remember him making a catch, breaking his forearm from a hit, and still scoring a TD. 

Absorbs two hits gets his arm broken in half in the process bounces off and scores agaist the Giants Matt Moore threw that ball....

 

Or in the 2005 playoffs when Jake threw a ball to Peanut Tillman and Steve Mugged him for it broke off and scored.

[Billy Love]

1 hour ago, Jackie Lee said:

Replay update- Our D-line is trash. Specifically the interior

I’m afraid week 1 against the Browns just might validate your  observation.

[Wundrbread33]

6 hours ago, BrianS said:

Does Justin Jefferson come down with that ball?  Does Stefon Diggs come down with that ball?  Does Davante Adams?  Cooper Kupp?  I would answer yes to all of those.  Because that's what WR1's do in the NFL.

RA did not.  Draw your own conclusions.

The safety made a great play. He’s a professional too. 

Those guys aren’t perfect either. Sometimes the defender just makes a better play. 

[Harbingers]

7 hours ago, Jackie Lee said:

Your takeaway from that first series is Robbie should have caught this? He was where he was supposed to be and got his hands on it. 

 

Elite WR’s make the catch. Trash doesn’t. 

[trueblade]

7 hours ago, BrianS said:

Does Justin Jefferson come down with that ball?  Does Stefon Diggs come down with that ball?  Does Davante Adams?  Cooper Kupp?  I would answer yes to all of those.  Because that's what WR1's do in the NFL.

RA did not.  Draw your own conclusions.

RA is our WR2. DJ is WR1. 

[Jackie Lee]

26 minutes ago, trueblade said:

RA is our WR2. DJ is WR1. 

I think these people will have something negative to say when Robbie catches a 50 yard bomb

[RJK]

As someone who’s spent a couple seasons watching Diggs…no, no he does not make that catch or catches like that. 

[Smithers]

19 hours ago, BrianS said:

Does Justin Jefferson come down with that ball?  Does Stefon Diggs come down with that ball?  Does Davante Adams?  Cooper Kupp?  I would answer yes to all of those.  Because that's what WR1's do in the NFL.

RA did not.  Draw your own conclusions.

Fair point.  When watching replays Robby had the ball in his hands before the secondary contact.  He really should have made that catch.  He’s being paid enough to make that catch.  Smitty made a living off making catches like that.  

[dynomite]

I blame the playcall. Someone posted a video in a different thread of a former qb talking about this play. They should have had another receiver going long to keep that safety off RA

[ForJimmy]

I mean it's 2 defenders making contact and one has his helmet in Robbie's chin.  I would have been VERY impressed if he did catch that.  The effort was there, but he isn't elite and we all know this.  I think RA is going to be good this year.  

[shaqattaq]

22 hours ago, Jackie Lee said:

Should have been a helmet to helmet flag honestly

Kinda hard to secure the ball when your head is smacked around so you can't watch it all the way in.

[shaqattaq]

22 hours ago, BrianS said:

Does Justin Jefferson come down with that ball?  Does Stefon Diggs come down with that ball?  Does Davante Adams?  Cooper Kupp?  I would answer yes to all of those.  Because that's what WR1's do in the NFL.

RA did not.  Draw your own conclusions.

Every team needs WR2's as well. Robbie is not a star, but he's not a bum either.

[RumHam]

15 hours ago, Wundrbread33 said:

The safety made a great play. He’s a professional too. 

Those guys aren’t perfect either. Sometimes the defender just makes a better play. 

He didn't get his hand on the ball. Baker got the ball in there. Robbie just needed to, ya know, catch it.