Does Marshall Even Make The 53?

[Asaria]

Watching the game tonight, I didn't even know Marshall was playing until Smitty said his name. After looking like a Gem in the preseason last year, he's done Jack Sh**. I know he's not had the best QB play, but then you look at Shi Smith who has put the work in and thrived with Baker under center.

I don't know if he'll be cut, but I could see them swapping him for Mims off the Jets.

[LinvilleGorge]

Would not be shocked to see him traded.

[TheCasillas]

I hate to say it, bc I was excited about him… I just dont see a place with him on the team 

[Jackie Lee]

That's without DJ and Robbie on the field. Only thing I saw was a Sam to TMJ underthrow sideline pass. Shi and Higgins are way ahead of him for me

[pantherclaw]

He'll make the team.  

[hepcat]

Who cares where he was drafted if he sucks and can’t practice. Put the best 53 on the roster.

[Jackie Lee]

13 minutes ago, hepcat said:

Who cares where he was drafted if he sucks and can’t practice. Put the best 53 on the roster.

Swap TMJ and Shi Smiths draft spots and all is well. It's not hard to justify cutting a number 2 pick when your number 6 was a steal. I still wouldn't credit that to Rhule or Fitt but I'll take it

[KillerKat]

2 hours ago, Jackie Lee said:

Swap TMJ and Shi Smiths draft spots and all is well. It's not hard to justify cutting a number 2 pick when your number 6 was a steal. I still wouldn't credit that to Rhule or Fitt but I'll take it

You wont credit Fitt, the guy who drafted him? What kind of dumbass logic is that?

[top dawg]

I think that it's a legitimate question. Rhule seems to have soured on him, and I can't say that he's wrong. What I will say is that another team--maybe even Carolina North--would probably find out a way to actually maximize his talent (provided he ever gets enough practice).

[Carl Spackler]

4 hours ago, hepcat said:

Who cares where he was drafted if he sucks and can’t practice. Put the best 53 on the roster.

Got the wrong coach for that 

[BIGH2001]

Dude is David Gettis but drafted higher. 

[mrcompletely11]

5 minutes ago, BIGH2001 said:

Dude is David Gettis but drafted higher. 

He looked sluggish last night.  Someone compared him to fun chess and that’s a solid match

[Rubi]

Disappointing 2nd round pick. Great physical traits / profile. Does nothing on the field with it. Oh well 

[Panthera onca]

He really doesn’t deserve to make the final 53 but he will due to his draft status. Smith looks like a keeper and is leaving Marshall in his wake.