Top 5 QBs taken over the last 12 years

[UpstatePantherfan]

6 minutes ago, JawnyBlaze said:

Go look at max duggan’s stats, he has improved every year for the last four years across the board, he has the size and measurable and he plays for TCU which Andy Dalton also played for (for all the “omg, such and such schools produce bad QBs” crowd)

plus we will draft his top WR in the 1st who is a bonafide first rounder anyway. I wonder if there is precedent for a QB and WR that played together in college to be drafted together by the same team. 

Edited November 1, 2022 by UpstatePantherfan

[saX man]

3 minutes ago, Jackie Lee said:

I feel like the 2021's college film looked way better than what we're seeing guys put up this year aside from Young and Hooker. Curious if teams learned their lesson reaching in that 2021 draft and will continue to be a little more patient picking QB's the way they were this past draft

I don't know about that...

2021 was what? Willis, Pickett and Corral who all had pretty shaky performances throughout the year.  And then people were convincing themselves Howell and Strong were the other tops, who scouts apparently had pegged as R4 and below.  Pickett was the only one consistently producing offense, but there were notable flags. Many went into the year thinking Corral & Strong were the guys and it turned out to be really no one, minus Pickett sorta who came out of nowhere and was a late-1st.

This year---Stroud and Bryce have been either at their expected level or exceeding it as Round 1 prospects.  And then yep, Hooker has bloomed out of nowhere. Penix would be the other to watch, who honestly, is kind of where I start to feel this class gets to that Willis/Corral/Ridder level, but I think he's still better.

The true deflated feeling many have in this current class is Richardson, Levis and Van Dyke not living up to expectations so far.  Those guys have the measurables, no injury history, less physical questions, and overall ceiling but have not followed through on the field yet.  

More season to be played but if we're comparing to 2021, the likes of McCall & Jaren Hall is where this class gets to the Willis/Corral/Ridder level.  

 

 

[Jackie Lee]

4 minutes ago, saX man said:

I don't know about that...

2021 was what? Willis, Pickett and Corral who all had pretty shaky performances throughout the year. 

 

 

2021 was Lawrence/Wilson/Fields/Jones, Lance didn't really play I don't think. I agree last years class didn't look much better than this 23 class

[JawnyBlaze]

10 minutes ago, UpstatePantherfan said:

Go look at max duggan’s stats, he has improved every year for the last four years across the board, he has the size and measurable and he plays for TCU which Andy Dalton also played for (for all the “omg, such and such schools produce bad QBs” crowd)

plus we will draft his top WR in the 1st who is a bonafide first rounder anyway. I wonder if there is precedent for a QB and WR that played together in college to be drafted together by the same team. 

We drafted one of Cam’s receivers (and his LT).  Neither lasted long.  I’ll look at Dugan but I imagine if he was as good as Stroud or Young I’d have heard more about him.  

[saX man]

Just now, Jackie Lee said:

2021 was Lawrence/Wilson/Fields/Jones, Lance didn't really play I don't think. I agree last years class didn't look much better than this 23 class

Oh flub, I'm going by season not actual year.  Compared to 21', I think it would depend on teams but Fields and Young would be between Lawrence and Jones, order of that #2-5 would vary. 

[top dawg]

55 minutes ago, saX man said:

We pick where we pick.  Just hope we pick the right guy.  

That's about the size of it. 

I'm looking at it a little differently anyway. We'll have two shots at getting this right. The QB that we draft, and Corral. Surely one will work out. 

[kungfoodude]

1 hour ago, Cdparr7 said:

A #1 pick doesn’t seem to do much justice unless you have a Luck or Newton in the draft- which there clearly isn’t this season. 
 

I mean, that is a 4-3 or 5-3 record at the #1 overall pick for a QB in that span(depends on how Trevor turns out).

I will take a 57-63% hit rate all day long.

[Jackie Lee]

Just now, top dawg said:

That's about the size of it. 

I'm looking at it a little differently anyway. We'll have two shots at getting this right. The QB that we draft, and Corral. Surely one will work out. 

I'm curious which vet they're gonna keep, or if they're gonna look at Jones/Minshew/Huntley. Depends on the HC and OC obviously. Slim pickings for vet QB's we haven't already been through

[Brooklyn 3.0]

So what's the point of this thread? Stick with PJ?

I mean ... you know how we got Cam, right? We drafted him.

[Move the Panthers to Raleigh]

So many threads coping with the fact that we may have already fuged up the draft.

Man, this team is gonna be ass for awhile if we mess this year up

[Gipetto]

Why is everyone giving up on matt corral already

Edited November 2, 2022 by Gipetto

[CmC2k]

If you identify a franchise QB in the draft, then you move up to get them whatever the price may be. Don't let 2020 happen again and miss out on Herbert because you didn't want to trade up.

[Aussie Tank]

It would be nice if PJ was talented enough for us to be able to draft Richardson at the top of the 2nd and let him develop into a world beater 

[rayzor]

Play as good as we can now.

Win as much as we can now.

And get the best QB we can in the draft.