Bryce Young is not ready to be a starting QB in the NFL

[Byrdman4real]

2 minutes ago, Jmac said:

Besides Bryce looking lost, Reich looks like he is bewildered half the time also. Doesn't instill confidence in them at all.

Reich is too passive, that's why his offense is too. Team needed a younger more aggressive coach. 

[CPantherKing]

It's ok.

We are 0-0

Remember that!

[Call Me James]

I dunno, huddlers pood me to hell last week for saying he doesn't have a live arm.

 

Lol

[OneBadCat]

18 minutes ago, Fright said:

Watch his college film. Most of his throws are to dudes wide open. He doesn’t throw them open or thread needles. He can find the open guy, but they have to be super wide open. If he didn’t play for Bama he’d be a 5th round project. Stroud should have been the pick, but yano, single mom household with no super computer brain over analyzed bullshit. 

Thats what i fear. The FO fell in love with the person not the player and they were too stupid to see past that.

He might be an amazing person with high character. Hell he might even deserve to be the #1 pick. But that doesn’t make him the best player. 

Edited September 19, 2023 by OneBadCat

[Pantha-kun]

Probably should have sat him but at this point you obliterate his confidence if he sucked for his first 2 starts and gets benched the rest of the season 

[Carl Spackler]

Andy Dalton came in and looked 3x worse against Lions backups, so if that's what you want, lol

[Mr. Scot]

28 minutes ago, Dave Gettleman's Shorts said:

never understood why they gave BY the starting role prior to training camp. let him earn it instead of just handing it to him

So...handle him like Matt Rhule would?

[Proudiddy]

Think...  how fuging wild is it that this guy canr complete a pass deeper than 20 yards AND you have to sub him out on short yardage.  I have never seen any fuging thing like this in my life and I just watched 3 years of a greasy ass car salesman coach the team with nothing but an expertise in business and marketing.  This poo is unreal.  We have two former pro QBs as the HC and QB coach with oodles of pro experience and they actually thought that poo was acceptable and went it did it.

[pantherj]

I would do an avatar bet with anyone that Young will not be benched this season. Also, if Young is so weak that he can't handle playing poorly this season, then it's already over for us. Spoiler alert, he looks like he thinks like a computer and is unfazed by the game.

[HardcoreHokie]

Would anyone here rather have Derek Carr ($150 million)?

Desmond Ridder?

Baker Mayfield?

That’s our division, chill bros.

 

 

[Dave Gettleman's Shorts]

5 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

So...handle him like Matt Rhule would?

Pat Mahomes didn't start his first season. Rodgers didn't start till year 3.

Cam started training camp his rookie year as 3rd string and worked his way up during camp and preseason.

It's not about Rhule ignoring his rookie QB or his bs 50/50 reps for Baker and Darnold. It's about learning and earning your reps before being named the starter. The game is just too fast for Bryce as we saw these past two games.

[OneBadCat]

6 minutes ago, pantherj said:

I would do an avatar bet with anyone that Young will not be benched this season. Also, if Young is so weak that he can't handle playing poorly this season, then it's already over for us. Spoiler alert, he looks like he thinks like a computer and is unfazed by the game.

My concern there is that because Young doesn’t have elite physical traits he will get baited by disguises. There’s isn’t going to be any magic. Either the answer is schemed open or it’s a throw away. 

[Jackie Lee]

 

[dnice5268]

It's the play calling, they are not letting him go out there and just play, he is thinking too much, they should have gotten a receiver like Zay Flowers, Jordan Addison  or Josh Downs to play in the slot to work  the middle of  the  field  or take the top of the defense, too many  receivers on the team with the same skillset, all bunched in no speed in the slot,the guy they got from  Kansas City can do it if they even try letting him