Would you trade Derrick Brown to get a top QB prospect?

[SCO96]

2 minutes ago, TheBigKat said:

This team can win with a Jake Delhomme

 

we don’t need a gunslinger 

I think most of us agree with you. Unfortunately, we don't have anything close to Jake on our roster. Honestly, I believe this team could earn a playoff spot Kerry Collins or Steve Beuerlein at starting QB.

[heel31ok]

35 minutes ago, hepcat said:

It’s clear as we can all see, and hopefully the franchise can see, that Bryce Young is never going to be able to be a winning NFL QB. The Panthers have won in spite of his god awful QB play. For every miracle fourth down conversion he makes, he made 10 awful plays to get the Panthers into a position where they needed a miracle to begin with. 

So to my point, would you trade the Panthers best defensive player to get a big time QB prospect? Obviously the 2026 draft is looking weak so maybe it’ll be in 2027. But the Panthers might have to give up something to be able to move up and move on from Bryce. 

Wow wish someone would have seen this before we traded up to get him.

This is just the unnecessary fallout from that castotrophic decision.

[LinvilleGorge]

3 minutes ago, TheBigKat said:

This team can win with a Jake Delhomme

 

we don’t need a gunslinger 

Jake was a gunslinger.

[bigjohn]

No.

You don't trade an all-pro type player at any position for a "prospect".

[ThPantherFan]

1 hour ago, hepcat said:

It’s clear as we can all see, and hopefully the franchise can see, that Bryce Young is never going to be able to be a winning NFL QB. The Panthers have won in spite of his god awful QB play. For every miracle fourth down conversion he makes, he made 10 awful plays to get the Panthers into a position where they needed a miracle to begin with. 

So to my point, would you trade the Panthers best defensive player to get a big time QB prospect? Obviously the 2026 draft is looking weak so maybe it’ll be in 2027. But the Panthers might have to give up something to be able to move up and move on from Bryce. 

No

 

[L-TownCat]

No.  Give Dave a prototypical vet QB and build the roster.

[strato]

No you shouldn’t trade known quantities of that level a player for unknown. 
 

Throw all available QBs names in a hat, pull one out, he will be better than Bryce. 

[Pantherxtreme]

So in other words the Bears trade all over again. 

I'll pass bring a vet in here ala Daniel Jones for the Colts, Darnold for Seahawks and continue to build this roster up. 

[WarHeel]

Bryce was a “top QB” prospect.

 

Y'all love trading away anyone worth a damn to this franchise to get nothing in return. 

[Proudiddy]

No, because we don’t need a “top QB prospect” for us to seriously upgrade the QB position here.  Again, Joe Milton, Shedeur, Shough, Dart, Jameis, Flacco, Huntley, etc., all of those options were available for CHEAP this offseason.  They could’ve been had without giving up a player.  It was that fuging easy.

[Panthering]

Definitely not