Prime Tom Brady or Prime Aaron Rodgers - Who would you want?

[t96]

In my opinion, QBs can’t be compared across generations so there’s no such thing as a GOAT. And also my opinion, the conversation of greatest QB of the 2000s and 2010s generation is between just 2 players: Rodgers and Manning. Brees and Brady are in the tier below those 2. 
 

I wouldn’t think twice about taking Rodgers over Brady. Easy decision.

[Borat]

Rodgers is a better QB, Brady has played on better teams. 
 

[Mr. Scot]

1 minute ago, Basbear said:

What a prime John Elway? Carried teams to the Superbowl with nothing.

Elway's Super Bowl performances weren't exactly anything to write home about till later in his career 

[pantherclaw]

Brady has struggled with all world talent around him this year. Lol

[Basbear]

1 minute ago, Mr. Scot said:

Elway's Super Bowl performances weren't exactly anything to write home about till later in his career 

Carried the whole team, think about the other big names on those early teams. Rod Smith, a UDFA when the draft was like 14 rounds(who John made btw). Karl mecklenburg is about the only other name, he was the 98.76% of the team. 

[Davidson Deac II]

2 minutes ago, Basbear said:

Carried the whole team, think about the other big names on those early teams. Rod Smith, a UDFA when the draft was like 14 rounds(who John made btw). Karl mecklenburg is about the only other name, he was the 98.76% of the team. 

Randy Gradishar was probably the best linebacker not named Luke that I ever saw.  Although I think he only got to play a year or two with Elway.  

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

10 minutes ago, pantherclaw said:

Brady has struggled with all world talent around him this year. Lol

Only in November where he had a 10/7 TD/INT ratio, and maybee Sept

Sept: 6/3

Oct: 12/1

Nov: 10/7

Dec: 8/0

Total: 40/12 (one reg season game in January where he went 4/1)

Edited January 17, 2021 by Sean Payton's Vicodin

[GoPanthers123]

I’ll vote for the GOAT.  He owned AFC for two decades and was a fluke catch away from perfect season.

[Basbear]

Just now, Davidson Deac II said:

Randy Gradishar was probably the best linebacker not named Luke that I ever saw.  Although I think he only got to play a year or two with Elway.  

Dang thats a name I dont know, early broncos? 

[LinvilleGorge]

Yes please. I don't feel like there's a wrong answer here.

[Davidson Deac II]

6 minutes ago, Basbear said:

Dang thats a name I dont know, early broncos? 

Late 70's, early 80's.  Played on some Denver teams that were mostly defense, very little offense.  Probably would be better known if they had won a SB or two.   

Edited January 17, 2021 by Davidson Deac II

[Zod]

1 minute ago, TSLA said:

I would take Russell Wilson over Rodgers any day of the week. 

[hepcat]

I will take the guy with way more Super Bowls

[LinvilleGorge]

4 minutes ago, TSLA said:

I would take Russell Wilson over Rodgers any day of the week. 

Good lord...