How was this forward progress?

[Star Platinum]

1 minute ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Oh, incompetence was definitely at play. You absolutely cannot after the fact make a determination of stopped forward progress on a play that has resulted in a fumble with no whistle on the field. That's inexcusable officiating. 

Fair point I only felt that the previous fumble skewed the call

[Snake]

When Booger is the ref you know we are about to get screwed. 

[TheoJay10]

Same as the Cotchery no catch in the SB. We have a history of inexcusably dumb officiating in big games. 

[mc52beast]

Does anyone know if this is a reviewable play or not? 

[Zod]

It wasn't. It was a blown call and they will apologize for it this week.

[HPPantherzfan]

It wasn’t, at all but this wasn’t the only bad call in the game.  Just this was a potential 14 point swing in the game let’s not mention the other at least 7 bad calls

[usmcpanthers]

1 minute ago, mc52beast said:

Does anyone know if this is a reviewable play or not? 

forward progress isnt reviewable, which is total BS

[LinvilleGorge]

5 minutes ago, Star Platinum said:

Fair point I only felt that the previous fumble skewed the call

When in doubt, go with the call that's reviewable. I don't know if refs are taught that but if they aren't they should be. This is why they hold the whistle so much on plays that look like they should be blown dead sometimes. Once that whistle blows the play is dead. What you REALLY can't do as a ref is manufacture a whistle that was never blown and call a play dead after the fact due to the result of the play. That's how you get accused of game fixing or score fixing because it sure looks like you're doing some fixing. 

[Star Platinum]

1 minute ago, LinvilleGorge said:

When in doubt, go with the call that's reviewable. I don't know if refs are taught that but if they aren't they should be. This is why they hold the whistle so much on plays that look like they should be blown dead sometimes. Once that whistle blows the play is dead. What you REALLY can't do as a ref is manufacture a whistle that was never blown and call a play dead after the fact due to the result of the play. That's how you get accused of game fixing it score fixing because it sure looks like you're doing some fixing 

True I personally don’t understand the idea behind “yeah we know but that’s not reviewable and therefore not fixable” it’s a tad illogical 

[Chief Keek]

It wasn't, just another bullshit call by the referees

[Kuhndog94]

Ultimately cost us the game

[Carolina Cajun]

5 minutes ago, Zod said:

It wasn't. It was a blown call and they will apologize for it this week.

[DJ feed me moore]

worst reffing crew around, wont see them come playoff time.

[hepcat]

Panthers are victims of bad refereeing every game. It has to stop.