What is Rhule going to give up for Jimmy G?

[SCO96]

We don't have enough assets in the draft to make run for Jimmy G. even if we wanted to (which most of us don't). And as someone pointed out, the 2023 draft choices should be untouchable unless it'something like a 5th, 6th, or 7th rounder choice.

Now if Jimmy got cut, that changes things. I'd consider signing him to a 3 year deal if the terms were reasonable and use this draft/offseason to address the O-line for 2022. If a promising prospect was on the board in round 5,6, or 7 then I'd take them and let PJ go. I would even consider letting Sam go and taking the cap hit.

I'd prefer trying to get a better prospect for QB in the 2023 class. If our 2023 picks are intact we could afford to move up and take a guy and get him ready to assume the starting job by 2024/2025. 

Thing is, I don't think Jimmy would want to come here. In fact I don't know why any veteran QB would want to play in Carolina unless it's their last chance to get starting job or roster spot. We've mismanaged so poorly since Rhule arrived that I think I'd rather ride with Sam in 2022. This would likely result in Rhule getting fired and allowing a new group of coaches to come in and right the ship. Then again, maybe...just maybe...McAdoo can make Sam a serviceable guy who can hold things down until we can draft a guy next year.


 

[Leotiger]

Probably going to take our 1st … maybe they flip jimmy g and 3rd to us for our 1st … At this point he is just a major upgrade hell it could be more then the 1st rounder… plus rumored raiders asking price for carr is 2 1sts….. 

 

we need a qb no matter what … hopefully it’s resolved before draft cuz if not … our highest pick will probably be a qb …… 

 

 

 

[Pimpdaddy]

we have to draft a QB every year till we get one.....vs qb wasteland....

[Jackie Lee]

That’s what the 49ers needed in the last 1:46 on Sunday, with the faint hopes of knotting the score with a field goal or in their wildest dreams, putting the game away with a 75-yard touchdown drive. Instead, San Francisco got two things: A drive that featured an incompletion, a reception for -3 yards and an interception. And a titanic reminder that Garoppolo is a quarterback problem, not a solution

https://sports.yahoo.com/49-ers-doubt-in-jimmy-garoppolo-drove-them-to-pursue-aaron-rodgers-and-draft-trey-lance-sundays-nfc-title-game-showcased-why-081345068.html 

 

Pretty straight forward damning assessment of Jimmy G not being the guy, and the 49ers already knew it a year ago

[joemac]

16 hours ago, Call Me James said:

It's more likely Lance gets traded. 

LOL what?  They just traded 3 first round picks for him last season.  No way in Hell does Lance get traded.  They've mortgaged their future for the guy.  He has not had a chance to even show them what he can do yet.  Why would they trade him and keep Jimmy G?

[joemac]

14 hours ago, KillerKat said:

Darnold, CMC, Anderson for Jimmy G and a 3rd.

CMC in the San Francisco offense would be absolutely filthy. 

[PNW_PantherMan]

6 minutes ago, joemac said:

LOL what?  They just traded 3 first round picks for him last season.  No way in Hell does Lance get traded.  They've mortgaged their future for the guy.  He has not had a chance to even show them what he can do yet.  Why would they trade him and keep Jimmy G?

Yeah.  Jimmy G would have had to go full Joe Flacco and play at a high level, and win the Super Bowl for that to be the case.

[KatsAzz]

It would be beyond  foolish for the Panthers to repeat these ineffective actions. One popular formulation presents this point harshly:

The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result.

[top dawg]

1 minute ago, PNW_PantherMan said:

Yeah.  Jimmy G would have had to go full Joe Flacco and play at a high level, and win the Super Bowl for that to be the case.

Shcefty just said this morning that the 49ers still believe Lance is going to be special.

[Green-Ghost]

I am an Ole Miss graduate.  1983.  So I am a little Biased.   I think whoever you get needs to be accurate.  Unbelievable accuracy is what made Brees so powerful.

the question I have is, “How accurate is JG”. 

BTW -  Matt Corral will most likely be available when it is the Panthers to choose, in the draft.  Matt took Ole Miss to their 1st ever 10 win season.  He has broken many of Eli Manning’s records.  He is extremely accurate.  

I think he is worth, at least a look.

[Catsfan69]

We have higher ceiling with Darnold. 

That's just a fact.

No to Jimmy and all Vets like him.

[Catsfan69]

2 hours ago, Jackie Lee said:

That’s what the 49ers needed in the last 1:46 on Sunday, with the faint hopes of knotting the score with a field goal or in their wildest dreams, putting the game away with a 75-yard touchdown drive. Instead, San Francisco got two things: A drive that featured an incompletion, a reception for -3 yards and an interception. And a titanic reminder that Garoppolo is a quarterback problem, not a solution

https://sports.yahoo.com/49-ers-doubt-in-jimmy-garoppolo-drove-them-to-pursue-aaron-rodgers-and-draft-trey-lance-sundays-nfc-title-game-showcased-why-081345068.html 

 

Pretty straight forward damning assessment of Jimmy G not being the guy, and the 49ers already knew it a year ago

That interception was 100% on the receiver. 

[Soul Rebel]

Jimmy G is exactly what we don't want. Instead of 5-12, we'd be 8-9.....worse draft pick to actually find a QB/OL in '23 and saddled with another QB on a high contract. 

He's better than Darnold and Teddy, but in a way that a Hyundai is an upgrade over a Kia (no offense to any Hyundai/Kia drivers).

Pass.

[Michael G]

I doubt we pay for Jimmy G. I think we go cheap if we can. Macadoo was the OC when Minshew was drafted by and started for Jacksonville. We kicked the tires on a trade for him last year. it would not surprise me.