Riot: Panthers to take a major swing at QB?

[PNW_PantherMan]

Rhule is really an idiot if he does this.  Jimmy G couldn't get the 49ers a Lombardi and they are STACKED.  They have a good run game, George Kittle and Deebo Samuel.  They have a very talented defense.  But he still wasn't enough.

Why would anyone think Jimmy G is going to be the answer for a significantly worse roster?  We might as well trade for Jared Goff.

[NanuqoftheNorth]

21 minutes ago, PNW_PantherMan said:

Rhule is really an idiot if he does this.  Jimmy G couldn't get the 49ers a Lombardi and they are STACKED.  They have a good run game, George Kittle and Deebo Samuel.  They have a very talented defense.  But he still wasn't enough.

Why would anyone think Jimmy G is going to be the answer for a significantly worse roster?  We might as well trade for Jared Goff.

Or keep who we've got and allow better football minds (hopefully) to make these decisions once Matt Rhule is fired later this year.

[The Lobo]

28 minutes ago, NanuqoftheNorth said:

Or keep who we've got and allow better football minds (hopefully) to make these decisions once Matt Rhule is fired later this year.

Ultimately, this is the right call. Don’t mortgage picks, draft smart and roll with Sam. He’s rhules project, he should have to stick by him. Once Rhule is fired, move forward with another qb and have  loads of cap space. 

[rayzor]

Yeah, I kind of think forcing him to stick with Darnold instead of letting him bounce around with a new QB every year is the best way to go for the future. 

You thought he was something special, roll with him. He's blown it on how many QBs so far....do we really want to trust him with anymore? 

What, in his track record, makes anyone think he'll get it right this time?

[Dilla]

We don't have the assets to take a major swing. Either eat it and stick with Darnold for one year or sign veteran looking prove he can still start to a one year deal, like Mariota, Taylor, or Trubisky. No more draft picks, please.

[Carl Spackler]

4 hours ago, LinvilleGorge said:

He's going to keep swinging (and striking out) until he gets fired.

Seven years means seven huge contracts for seven different bad quarterbacks. 

[Aussie Tank]

5 hours ago, Mr. Scot said:

He has a no trade clause and we're not on his list of approved teams.

Nor are we likely to be added to it.

Same as Watson but everyone keeps riding that train 

[Aussie Tank]

2 hours ago, Dilla said:

We don't have the assets to take a major swing. Either eat it and stick with Darnold for one year or sign veteran looking prove he can still start to a one year deal, like Mariota, Taylor, or Trubisky. No more draft picks, please.

Mariota would be nice 

[Tomcatn]

8 hours ago, Jackie Lee said:

It's straight out of the Arena Football League

They should've just kept WFT

 

[Mike2.0]

7 hours ago, PNW_PantherMan said:

Rhule is really an idiot if he does this.  Jimmy G couldn't get the 49ers a Lombardi and they are STACKED.  They have a good run game, George Kittle and Deebo Samuel.  They have a very talented defense.  But he still wasn't enough.

Why would anyone think Jimmy G is going to be the answer for a significantly worse roster?  We might as well trade for Jared Goff.

To be fair, the 49ers were 20-10 up going into the fourth quarter against the Chiefs in the Super Bowl, then proceeded to concede 21 points. Not the first time a team with Kyle Shanahan calling the plays has choked in the fourth quarter in a Super Bowl.

That said, Jimmy G is not the answer for our quarterback position unless he’s being used as a bridge while we develop the long term answer to the quarterback position.

[BrianS]

Jimmy G . . . behind this line?  The guy is made of glass.  He'll be IR'ed by October here.

[LinvilleGorge]

8 hours ago, PNW_PantherMan said:

Rhule is really an idiot if he does this.  Jimmy G couldn't get the 49ers a Lombardi and they are STACKED.  They have a good run game, George Kittle and Deebo Samuel.  They have a very talented defense.  But he still wasn't enough.

Why would anyone think Jimmy G is going to be the answer for a significantly worse roster?  We might as well trade for Jared Goff.

In Rhule's mind, the only thing a QB like Jimmy G or Teddy or Darnold is missing is his brilliant coaching and tutelage.  Oh, Teddy and Sam? Rhule was just wrong about those particular guys. The process is still working. 1000%

Actually, in retrospect Rhule would almost certainly blame Teddy on Joe Brady while Sam was a "group decision". Shirking any and all blame is what Matt Rhule does best.

[45catfan]

9 hours ago, ellis said:

Spoke w/ Mark Schofield yesterday. Mark does great work for USA Today, particular on the film side. He suggested Garoppolo would be a good scheme fit for McAdoo in Carolina, though I didn’t necessarily see it as endorsement by Mark for Carolina actually making that move. I do think there is some validity to the buzz the Carolina might try to pursue Jimmy G, based on prior and recent reporting from Breer, this analysis by Schofield, and my own sourcing. 

 

I said this last year when the 49ers drafted Lance that if Darnold was a bust, we would be looking at Jimmy G this year.  It didn't take a rocket scientist to figure out they weren't going to keep both guys beyond this past season and Jimmy G would be available.

[45catfan]

36 minutes ago, BrianS said:

Jimmy G . . . behind this line?  The guy is made of glass.  He'll be IR'ed during training camp here.

FIFY