Poll: What do you want Panthers to do for QB?

[rippadonn]

*OFFICIAL MYLES MURPHY BANDWAGON MEMBER*

 

[NAS]

Interesting results, too close to call

[Basbear]

4 minutes ago, NAS said:

Interesting results, too close to call

In a rare case, most of them make sense. 

[Peon Awesome]

I think the options are too open ended. If any of the following happened, I'd be happy, roughly in order:

1. Trade 2 1sts and change for Stroud or Bryce Young

2. Stay at 9 and take Richardson

3. Sign Carr to a deal of no more than $30 million per year with 90% of the guarantees accounted for in his 1st year.

4. Combination of 2 + 3 is fine as well

 

So what do I not want?

1. Trading 3 1sts for anyone

2. Trading up for Levis or Richardson

3. Not drafting any qb and having only Corral and someone like Darnold or Brissett

4. Giving Carr a big multiyear deal with guarantees that tie him to us for at least 3 years.

 

Edited February 16, 2023 by Peon Awesome

[Daddy_Uncle]

I want them to be aggressive and go get our QB. We will live with trading trading draft picks. We have good pieces. We need our QB

[scratched]

Anything that involves trading away picks is a risk not worth taking. We sign Carr, keep Darnold and Corrall. When 1 of the 4 top QBs slide to 9, see how bad somebody wants them. Gain more draft capital with the 9 pick. We now have a competent staff that could have this turned around really quick with a good draft in 2023. Draft a starting TE, an EDGE guy, a starting caliber LB and CB. I feel like Shaq is going to be a cap casualty, and I'm good with that. So a LB or 2 will be needed.

[thennek]

McCown as the bridge QB, and Reich as the backup #2.

If not that, sign Carr to be the #1, and Darnold to be the #2.

[glenwo2]

On 2/16/2023 at 4:22 PM, thennek said:

McCown as the bridge QB, and Reich as the backup #2.

If not that, sign Carr to be the #1, and Darnold to be the #2.

 

Was this an attempt at Humor?

 

 

[thennek]

14 minutes ago, glenwo2 said:

 

Was this an attempt at Humor?

 

 

Of course 

[Day1PanthersFan]

I don't envy the Panthers coaching staff, going in either direction could blow up in our face 

I don't see any great option at QB, but hopefully they will pull it off 

[raleigh-panther]

As shared  in another post, pick your poison 

[gorillamilitia13]

On 2/15/2023 at 9:24 AM, t96 said:

Sign Carr as bridge. Get Stroud or Young (ideally Stroud) even if it means trading up.

Carr is not a bridge and probably isn't looking to go somewhere where he is seen as one

[gorillamilitia13]

On 2/16/2023 at 4:09 PM, Daddy_Uncle said:

I want them to be aggressive and go get our QB. We will live with trading trading draft picks. We have good pieces. We need our QB

Exactly our young core won't be young forever. You gotta take risks if you want to be successful. 

[Raleigh PF]

IIRC, the prediction for the 2021 draft was Lawrence at 1, Fields at 2 and potentially two other QBs going in the top-10. By the time the combine shook out and players had their pro days, things changed. All of the sudden, Wilson and Lance were the hot targets and Fields dropped off.

My point is, I seriously doubt these four QBs go in the first six picks. Free agency is going to weed out the teams in the top 10 who decide to sign a vet and have the cap space for it. There will be choices for the Panthers at 9, I have no doubt. I'd be happy to have one of those choices and maybe resign Darnold or sign Brissett until either Corral or the new draft pick step up.