Which Panther was the GOAT?

[Hotsauce]

Who ya got?

[OneBadCat]

Has to be Luke if we’re being objective. He retired early but he maximized his potential while being the most cerebral MLB the NFL has ever seen. He single handily kept us in games by putting his lesser talented teammates in the right position. He was without a doubt the best between the ears and was athletically a beast also. He was also a total pro and upstanding dude..

For me. 

1. Luke

2. Smith

3. Cam

4. Peppers

In terms of who I’m the biggest fans of at this moment

1. Cam

2. Smith (GOAT pound for pound)

3. Luke

4. Peppers

[LegioX]

Steve Smith. No question...and it’s not even close

[Mr Mojo Risin]

Quarterbacks are the most important part of every team. And it is also the most challenging position to play. Cam is my vote

Steve Smith is my all time favorite player. But in terms of what each player meant to the team I gotta go with Cam.

[Harbingers]

Luke on D, Smitty on O. 

[BrianS]

It's between Luke and Smitty.  I could make a good argument for either.

[Carl Spackler]

Cam Newton is the best player we've ever had and I'm not certain it won't stay that way.

[Jon Snow]

Gotta go with JJ as he has outlasted them all, except for Sir Purr.  But I here Purr is on the trading block so it looks like JJ it is.

[Greatman77]

Steve Smith was the most exciting, and pound for pound toughest player the Panthers ever had. Gotta go with him, especially since he was not an early round pick. Luke is a close second.

[Shotgun]

The only MVP we've ever had.

[jfra78]

1 Smith

2 Cam

3 Peppers

4 Luke

All 4 of these guys are Panthers Greats, but Smitty is The Goat

[ECUPantherFan]

1) Luke

2) Smitty

3) Cam

[TheRumGone]

Cam

[My Goodness My Guinness]

Gotta say Luke. He's a top 2 MLB of all time, if not the GOAT. Peppers is probably a top 10-15 DE of all-time, but also wasn't here for a substantial amount of time. Funny thing is, Smith and Cam weren't all-time greats at their position, but they were two of the most electric players that the NFL has ever seen and were a blast to watch. 

I'd characterize it like this:

GOAT: Luke

Gamechanger: Cam

Leader: Thomas m'fing Davis