Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

No more Watson threads. Use this one or one of the other 20 existing ones.


rayzor
 Share

Recommended Posts

3 hours ago, jb2288 said:

We already gave you two? The Seahawks and the Chiefs both did it. Common denominator? Star rookie QB on that first contract. 

Again, see Bengals. I'm too lazy to look it up, but in the last 10 years who has won a Super Bowl besides Brady/Manning/Rookie deal QB... Stafford this year? Flacco maybe? 

First, the Seahawks were not a patient rebuild. They lost patience with Holmgren/Hasselbeck. Dumped Holmgren after 1 bad season after having success but coming up short for 5 straight seasons. Brought in Jim Mora and dumped him in 1 season. Went to Carroll and pressured him to win. He was on the hot seat after 3 QBs in 2 seasons and saved himself with Wilson winning quickly when Matt Flynn was brought in to lead the team. Then winning a SB in Carroll's 4th season. This was not patience at all. It was win now or you're out.

Second, the Chiefs were giving their coaches 3 seasons to win. Edwards out in 3 seasons, Haley out in 2.5 seasons, Crennel out in 1.5 seasons. Reid came in and won immediately like he did in Philadelphia. He did it with Alex Smith in year 1. So, because there was immediate winning he got 4 years. Ownership and the front office were still not happy and they were going to put Reid on the hot seat if he did not find a new QB and move on from Smith. Hunt, Dorsey, and Veach had to light a fire under Reid to move the franchise from contender to champion. They did not want a 10 year situation with Alex Smith the way Reid carried on with McNabb. Reid was pushed to make this change after his 4th year with the Chiefs (and he was winning with Alex Smith).

Neither of these franchise case studies show any form of a long and patient rebuild. It was win now and win big or you're out! No patience and move on from a QB who keeps coming up short.

Third, Foles, Wilson, Brady, Flacco, Manning, Mahomes, and Stafford over the past 10 years. Mahomes and Flacco are the only 1st round QBs who have won the SB with the team that drafted them over the last 10 years. There are 3 teams who won a SB with a QB they drafted in the 3rd/6th round.

Burrow didn't win a SB and that will likely be his one and only shot.

The lesson is, don't draft a QB in the first round and think you're going to win a SB with them. Better chance at drafting a mid round QB and building a defense with those 1st round picks, or trading for a proven 1st round QB and giving them full control after you've built a team they feel they can win a championship with as their unquestioned leader.

I wish people would stop fantasizing about the 1st round rookie franchise QB who will take them all the way and give them a dynasty.

The last 9 dynasties are Chiefs with Mahomes, Patriots with Brady, Seahawks with Wilson, Steelers with Roethlisberger, Rams with Warner, Broncos with Elway, Packers with Favre, Cowboys with Aikman, and 49ers with Montana.

All of these dynasties were winning consistently and in the playoffs by their 3rd season. All had good championship minded head coaches that could roster build and prepare their teams well. Walsh, Johnson, Belichick and Holmgren found their QB from the start. Vermeil lucked into his QB in his lame duck season. Carroll and Reeves spotted their QB while on the hot seat in their 3rd season. Reid and Cowher were winning out the gate, but tied themselves to QBs that couldn't get it done and had to be persuaded by ownership/gm to move on from Alex Smith/Kordell Stewart or the team.

None of these coaches or franchises were patient. Just a couple stubborn coaches that were winning from year one regardless of their QB.

6th rounder in Brady, Undrafted with Warner, 1 pick away from being a 4th rounder in Montana, 3rd round pick in Wilson, 2nd rounder in Favre, and 1st rounders in Aikman/Elway/Roethlisberger/Mahomes

We can all agree Aikman, Elway, and Roethlisberger rank below Brady, Montana, and Warner. Aikman had a consistent dynasty with little impact as QB, Elway was on the verge of a decade long failed dynasty, and Roethlisberger's dynasty was consistently up and down.

We can keep going back too with the Redskins-Theismann, Steelers-Bradshaw, Cowboys-Staubach, Dolphins-Griese, Colts-Unitas, and Packers-Starr.

So, 5 of 15 QBs from NFL dynasties were drafted in the 1st round by the team they led. Only 1 of these 1st round QBs carried their teams to success - Mahomes. Compare that to 8 of the QBs not taken in the 1st round carrying their teams to successful dynasties.

Edited by CPantherKing
  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Scott Fowler from observer   An excerpt  from larger article gotta say, i am not sure what Canales or Young were  thinking in the final 2 mins  they both looked like they have never a 2 mon drill in their lives    Unprepared   Let’s just throw and hope was the strategy  Add to it,why leggett, the most unreliable receiver, was targeted so much during that drive is beyond me      With a chance to be unforgettable, Panthers’ final drive was one to forget BY SCOTT FOWLER [email protected] 4 hrs ago The Carolina Panthers lost again Sunday, 27-22 to Arizona, but let’s at least give them some credit for their heartbreaking creativity. This, at least, was not a rout like Week 1. Yes, the Panthers (0-2) did a whole lot of nothing through the beginning of the third quarter against Arizona (2-0), falling behind, 27-3. Then they did a whole lot of something, scoring 19 unanswered points under the direction of quarterback Bryce Young. Then the special teams recovered an onside kick by punter Sam Martin to, quite remarkably, get the ball back, down only 27-22 with 1:55 and 51 yards left to snag the win. And one timeout, too. After finishing three straight possessions with touchdowns, the Panthers would need to do it a fourth time to pull off what statistically would have been the largest comeback in franchise history. But while there was no quit in this team Sunday, there was no comeback either, and nothing but nonsense in that last “march,” which ended 46 yards away from the goal line. Let’s go through a little of that final drive for the Panthers, shall we? Young, who had played a horrible first quarter and then a terrific second half, reverted to first-quarter form. He was 0-for-6 on the drive. He only targeted Tetairoa McMillan, the rookie that is clearly the team’s best receiver, one time. When all else was failing, the option of throwing a jump ball to T-Mac — drafted No. 8 overall for exactly this sort of situation — should have been utilized. It wasn’t. Head coach Dave Canales suggested that the Cardinals started shifting their coverage toward McMillan. Said the rookie afterward to reporters when asked what the Cardinals did to limit him on the last drive: “I’m not too sure. It looked like regular defense to me. That last drive only lasted as long as it did because of three defensive penalties on Arizona, which kept Carolina in the game (defensive holding to negate what would have been a Young turnover; roughing the passer; offsides).   Now it is true that the Panthers’ offensive line was threadbare by then, with two starters out. This made the degree of difficulty harder for Young and everyone else. But the Cardinals defense was also banged up, as their defensive backs had been going down like dominoes. So how do you solve Arizona’s suddenly fearsome pass rush? Screens. Quick hitters. Chuba Hubbard in the flat. Maybe even a shovel pass to a tight end. There was plenty of time — what there wasn’t was plenty of yardage, nor enough flexibility from Canales. One of Young’s six incompletions was a pass to Xavier Legette, who to me at that point shouldn’t have been in the game. That pass went incomplete of course, because Legette — the Panthers’ first-round draft pick in 2024 — had what was undoubtedly the worst statistical lines in Carolina history. Young targeted Legette eight times. Eight! I have no idea why. Legette caught one. One! And it went for minus-2 yards, meaning Legette entered the game with 10 yards receiving this season and left it with eight. Now to be fair, Young (35-55-328 yards, with three TDs) had gotten Carolina back into the thing. Hunter Renfrow had a breakout game at slot receiver, scoring twice. McMillan didn’t score, but had his first 100-yard receiving game. Tight end Ja’Tavion Sanders and wide receiver Brycen Tremayne were also very good. And the comeback happened after Young about lost the game for the Panthers in the first quarter, fumbling the ball away on a strip-sack that led directly to a return touchdown and then throwing an ill-advised pass under pressure that resulted in a wounded-duck interception and three more points. Said Canales after the game about Young: “Sometimes it ain’t the worst thing, if you’re in that situation, to take a sack. I also know he makes some magical plays.” We saw both on Sunday. Young held the ball too long sometimes, including on Carolina’s final offensive play (a fourth-down sack). He also made some magic, sometimes throwing between three guys at once, sometimes escaping a sack attempt and keeping his eyes downfield for a touchdown. So there were some things that were better Sunday. Carolina only scored 10 points in Week 1; this time the Panthers had 22. The run defense improved. Young, after playing the first five quarters of the season as if he didn’t belong in the NFL, finally looked like he did again for those three consecutive TD marches. But that final drive?! Listen, Arizona was ripe to be beaten at that point. NFL onside kicks didn’t succeed about 94% of the time in 2024, yet this one did after a Cardinal misplayed it. Arizona had lost 19 points of its 24-point lead at that point. The Panthers, who had never successfully come back from more than 17 points down before, were close to a signature win for both Canales and Young. And then… total letdown. Again, let’s emphasize, the clock was very little factor. Carolina didn’t have 15 seconds left to score; the Panthers had 115 seconds left. And a timeout. And only 51 yards to navigate. Momentum was firmly on the Panthers’ side. These were the moments where Drew Brees killed the Panthers, time and again, when he played for New Orleans. Three-step drops. Eight yards here. Twelve yards there. Right down the field. But for the Panthers, every play looked the same — Young on a deep drop. Scanning, scanning. The pocket breaking down. Then, either a heave, or some scurrying around and then a heave. Or a sack. All the blitz-killing plays that the Panthers have at their disposal — they didn’t run any of them, it seemed like, except a Hubbard run that netted 3 yards. The Panthers’ best plays were Arizona penalties. Other than that, it all went south. Carolina couldn’t adjust to the Arizona adjustments. Needing a touchdown, the Panthers never got closer than the Arizona 33. And so that was that.   At least there was some hope. At least the game was exciting in the final two minutes. But, as has happened so often in the past eight seasons, when it was winning time for Carolina, it turned into losing time.
    • Ditching XL is addition by subtraction. I 100% believe Thielen would tell him where to line up  every snap and explain his route. Through 2 games he has shown 0 comprehension of the play book. I’m not absolving Young at all but XL is  supposed to be his second read, but dude runs the wrong routes and gets boxed out by guys who are 4” shorter.  At least Coker has shown aptitude to be a real NFL receiver. 
    • I'm trying to be as pragmatic and as un reactionary as possible. And once again multiple things can be true  His draft last year was disastrously terrible. X looks like an absolute bust. Brooks hasn't played. Wallace looks like a miss. But demani needs more pt, cws is solid and Coker has shown promise This draft cannot be judged after 2 games esp with a dc who doesn't want to play them. But tmac looks legit. Princely has promise. The rest is a ?  Has he made mistakes? Undoubtedly.  Is the roster better than it was 2 years ago? I'd say yes. I'd say our biggest problems are still the ones we had 2 years ago - Bryce and evero.  And as I've said before, at least he hasn't traded any future picks. Yet.  So IMHO Morgan is a mixed bag but not a total bust. Yet.
×
×
  • Create New...