Trading for Sean Payton vs Settling for Steve Wilks

[ForJimmy]

7 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

 

First I don't even want Payton.  However, if you are going to make this kind of trade for a great HC, you better already have your QB which we don't.  Those picks can be used to trade for a vet QB or move around in the draft to acquire one.  Not worth it....

[Harbingers]

22 hours ago, CRA said:

this seems like my worst case scenario.  And I think Payton is just using us.  Nor do I want him. 

I don't want an old school DC.  That's Wilks.  Too conservative.  You can't change it. 

and Payton is horrible.  He is Sean Payton. 

I’d take Wilks over Payton any day of the week. Don’t make me hate the panthers Tepper. Don’t hire Payton. 

Edited January 19, 2023 by Harbingers

[pantherj]

I want Payton but not for two first round picks. We're got to stop playing dinosaur ball with mediocre QBs no matter who we chose as HC. 

[SmokinwithWilly]

2 hours ago, HPPantherzfan said:

/cdn-cgi/mirage/10ee685e5e5ec413d73154605278f5d1282157412d852602c75283839c8dc257/1280/https://www.carolinahuddle.com/uploads/monthly_2023_01/254519080_DoyourJob.thumb.jpg.1f57d1074b5079a6767fd184f870377f.jpg

 

 

[Mr. Scot]

Yeah, I'd be uncomfortable if I were him

[Gerry Green]

I just love how many Huddlers just KNOW that we can't win with Wilks. Give the guy the resources he needs, and let's go to war.

 

Now, it would be nice if he could upgrade McAdoo, or at least pair him with a guy that has actual experience developing young QB. Maybe try and upgrade Holcomb as well. Just let the guy pick his own staff for once,

 

I ain't giving NO anything. We either get Payton as a FA. Or not at all. And I personally am in the not at all group.

 

 

[Brooklyn 3.0]

4 minutes ago, Gerry Green said:

I just love how many Huddlers just KNOW that we can't win with Wilks. Give the guy the resources he needs, and let's go to war.

Now, it would be nice if he could upgrade McAdoo, or at least pair him with a guy that has actual experience developing young QB. Maybe try and upgrade Holcomb as well. Just let the guy pick his own staff for once,

I just love how many Huddlers just KNOW that we can't win with McAdoo and Holcomb. Give the guys the resources they need, and let's go to war.

[Gerry Green]

1 minute ago, Brooklyn 3.0 said:

I just love how many Huddlers just KNOW that we can't win with McAdoo and Holcomb. Give the guys the resources they need, and let's go to war.

 

Taking words out of context is always a strong strategy for a weak rebuttal. 

 

That said. Well played.

[frankw]

With that logic we could have given Matt Rhule another year too. If someone is content with what we've been doing more power to them I guess. No need to knock someone for looking in another direction though. By all accounts the team seems to agree.

[Mr. Scot]

 

[AggieLean]

There’s no other option? I’d like Kafka or Steichen. Would even settle for Reich. I don’t want Wilks, and I just feel Payton to whoever is a disaster forthcoming. I’d rather he go to Denver

[ickmule]

I have a feeling that whomever is hired many are going to de disappointed.  

[Jon Snow]

Just now, ickmule said:

I have a feeling that whomever is hired many are going to de disappointed.  

That is obvious.  I can't wait to see the overreacting either way. It will either be, all your SB's belong to us or this organization is trash. It should be great entertainment for a few weeks at least. 

[therealmjl]

Steve Wilks is a .500 ceiling head coach