Bryce Young - Good and Bad, what say you?

[NAS]

Bryce proved himself today, end of story

[Carolina Mike]

BY had a really good game. I hope it elevated his trade value. BY is NOT the future of the Carolina Panthers. BY still has more bad games than good games. Some of you Yo-yos get too high and too low. 

[Navy_football]

7 minutes ago, Tbe said:

I would say his play today was average by nfl standards. I’m factoring the defense he played against.

Definitely better than the abomination that was the first few games.

He needs to be consistent and better to be worth keeping though.

This is the 2nd most yards they've allowed to 1 QB all season. Lamar got them for 273 in a loss. He also ran all over them. But he's a different animal.

[CPF4LIFE]

 I dont think its matter of if bryce can step on a field and play pro ball at this point. Can he be good? Can he be elite? That's another questionable discussion that only a bryce stan wouldn't entertain. On a list of options he is still last for me. If I'm starting a team and I get to choose from him Sanders, ward, or maybe stroud. He is still at the bottom. 

[La Pantera]

7 minutes ago, countryboi said:

The Chiefs were 5th in total defense, they were probably the best defense we have played all season  

This.

they have the best run D in the league.

[Tbe]

6 minutes ago, Navy_football said:

This is the 2nd most yards they've allowed to 1 QB all season. Lamar got them for 273 in a loss. He also ran all over them. But he's a different animal.

Interesting. Thanks. Maybe there is real hope.

[PleaseCutStewart]

24 minutes ago, electro's horse said:

With the game on the line over two drives, Bruce threw it away on a must make third down, threw a couple bailout DPIs, and completed clutch handoffs. 

finally reached the elusive 7 ypa threshold 

Dude, I hate Bryce as much as the next guy (mainly because I wanted stroud), but saying he got bailed out on that DPI when he did a great job sidestepping pressure and saw theilen open is ridiculous. Correct read, good throw, and DB had no chance but to DPI or give up a TD.

I think most of us can realize Bryce had his either 2nd best or best game of his career today and let's hope it's the beginning of something 

[frankw]

This is realistically the second time he has had a "this is his best game as a pro" moment in nearly two full seasons. That's the definition of an anomaly until we see more of a sample size in the remaining games. We aren't even in Kyle Allen territory yet in terms of sample size.

But to his credit he is showing improvement as a passer within the structure of his game. The issue is can he ever be that kind of QB who will elevate those around him instead of needing everything to go perfectly to just throw for more than one or two touchdowns or lead his offense to 30 or more points? He's done that once in his career so far. And at the end of the day we still only put up 7 points on the board from the passing game today. The team as a whole came to play. That's progress from Canales. That's my biggest takeaway.

[electro's horse]

3 minutes ago, PleaseCutStewart said:

 

I think most of us can realize Bryce had his either 2nd best or best game of his career today and let's hope it's the beginning of something 

He absolutely had the best game of his career, and until the refs game thing drive it still netted 19 points, which is basically what he’s done his entire career.

if you just want to be helpful about an aberration and think it means he’s going to turn into something resembling what the panthers gave up for him, cool. But I’ve got his whole career backing up how I feel about him. Bryce defenders have one game and narratives. 

Edited November 24, 2024 by electro's horse

[Sir Big Spurr]

You can win with today’s Bryce Young. Can he sustain that and continue to improve, I have no idea. But todays Bryce Young was very good. 

[shaq]

20 minutes ago, Jackie Lee said:

I WANT him to throw the ball up to get PI calls instead of throwing it out of bounds lol. That's the whole point of not throwing it away when you have the option

He did throw the ball up multiple times?

[Carolina Cajun]

27 minutes ago, Panthering said:

That’s called passing the eye test right against a good defense

[Jmac]

I will give the kid credit. He looked much better today and is finally starting to get it (I hope).

If he can improve the rest of the season, it will allow them to stack the defense in FA and the draft.

Edited November 24, 2024 by Jmac

[Manna]

Good: He's improved on basically every area.

Bad: He's still developing.

I've been sour on him but the guy is proving me wrong by showing steady improvement since coming back as QB1.