Jump to content

  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Why the Panthers might Draft Herbert

MHS831

By MHS831,
in Carolina Panthers

Recommended Posts

MHS831 Grand Master

MHS831

Posted
Posted

 This is not to bash Cam or promote my views on what the Cats should do---I simply try to analyze the big picture.  Some of you will not be able to get past that.  I understand--no, I really don't.  Here is what we know (please add to this list if you think of something I forgot or did not know):

1.  The quarterback position in Carolina is shrouded in uncertainty, and there does not seem to be a player on the roster ready to become an NFL starter---since Cam has been injured for the past 2 seasons and is now recovering from surgery, he is included on this list of question marks. If he comes in and cannot perform as in the past, that would mean that he was hurt for most of his current contract--not a bargain as some of you suggest.  You can't build on that.

2.  The team has indirectly suggested that Cam will return, but with caveats--Cam vaguely shared these with the media when he mentioned 100%. Ideally, a healthy Cam in 2020 is the best plan--but so might a trade if he is healthy--if you think beyond 2020.  Cam is positive so we expect it from him, and keeping him on for a year could be advantageous for both parties.  However, if the plan is to develop the QB of the future to grow in a long-term process, giving a 31-year old QB who has an injury history and can no longer run like he once did is almost detrimental to the process.  If healthy, one season while the rookie develops is a good idea on paper--one season that gives the team a chance to address and work out the OL issues. 

3.  There is no guarantee that your draft position lands you the QB you need in 2021.   At least with the  7th pick, we know there is a good chance we get a top QB.   I have spent January and part of February relieved that we would not be tempted to take the Herbert bait.  But then came the SR Bowl.  Not that it changed his history, but it caused me to re-examine him.  I imagine the Panthers did the same thing.

4.  There is reason to think the Panthers will address OL, but not Tackle.  They have Little, and regardless of what we say about him, high second rounders are not dismissed so quickly.  All I know is at the EW all-star game, they interviewed 2 WRs, a TE, and a G.  There are no IOL worth the #7 pick.  While a majority here seem to want that franchise LT,  Thomas has been slipping on the websites maintained by people who don't know squat--but there has to be a reason.  So without a T, and if Brown is off the board or not, will they pass on a top QB?  I know, Herbert sucks in your expert analysis, and I know, Walter sucks....everybody sucks.   But this is based on facts and it demonstrates the sentiment of a lot of experts after Mobile.

" 1/30/20: In 2019, Herbert completed 67 percent of his passes for 3,471 yards with 32 touchdowns and six interceptions. He scored four rushing touchdown too, but Oregon didn't run run him as much. The senior has all the physical tools to be a good NFL starter with a powerful arm, mobility and accuracy. When Herbert is given time, he is utterly deadly in his ability to carve up a defense. He is not a vocal leader, and some teams want their quarterback to be that kind of presence in the huddle, on the sideline, and in the locker room. Herbert had a solid week at the Senior Bowl, and team sources told me that he interviewed well there. "

So what is there not to like? The numbers are there---the tools are there.  Would we regret it one day for not taking a QB in the draft when our situation was so murky at the time?

5. If the Panthers were going to take a QB, would they say that the are not? Probably.  The stakes are high early in the draft.  Even Cincinnati is throwing out mixed signals. Why would the Panthers let everyone know what they plan to do? 

To me, Herbert is the only player that makes this point somewhat feasible.  You have a QB with all the tools--he just needs a clean pocket. He has a "powerful arm, mobility, and accuracy,"  If he check out during the interviews, what more is there?  A year to develop behind a veteran. 

So maybe we have discounted the possibility of taking a QB too soon.  No, I do not believe the Panthers have committed to Cam beyond a "We will keep you for 2020 if you are healthy," and I do not believe they would say that they do not like any of the QBs in this year's draft--and if they did---more reason to suspect they will.

The thing is, nobody knows.  This is not 2015, when the decision would be a no brainer.  There are so many unknowns--so many variables--and if they fall in love with Herbert, this could happen.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
mrcompletely11 Grand Master

mrcompletely11

Posted
Posted
4 minutes ago, MHS831 said:

 This is not to bash Cam or promote my views on what the Cats should do---I simply try to analyze the big picture.  Some of you will not be able to get past that.  I understand--no, I really don't.  Here is what we know (please add to this list if you think of something I forgot or did not know):

1.  The quarterback position in Carolina is shrouded in uncertainty, and there does not seem to be a player on the roster ready to become an NFL starter---since Cam has been injured for the past 2 seasons and is now recovering from surgery, he is included on this list of question marks. If he comes in and cannot perform as in the past, that would mean that he was hurt for most of his current contract--not a bargain as some of you suggest.  You can't build on that.

2.  The team has indirectly suggested that Cam will return, but with caveats--Cam vaguely shared these with the media when he mentioned 100%. Ideally, a healthy Cam in 2020 is the best plan--but so might a trade if he is healthy--if you think beyond 2020.  Cam is positive so we expect it from him, and keeping him on for a year could be advantageous for both parties.  However, if the plan is to develop the QB of the future to grow in a long-term process, giving a 31-year old QB who has an injury history and can no longer run like he once did is almost detrimental to the process.  If healthy, one season while the rookie develops is a good idea on paper--one season that gives the team a chance to address and work out the OL issues. 

3.  There is no guarantee that your draft position lands you the QB you need in 2021.   At least with the  7th pick, we know there is a good chance we get a top QB.   I have spent January and part of February relieved that we would not be tempted to take the Herbert bait.  But then came the SR Bowl.  Not that it changed his history, but it caused me to re-examine him.  I imagine the Panthers did the same thing.

4.  There is reason to think the Panthers will address OL, but not Tackle.  They have Little, and regardless of what we say about him, high second rounders are not dismissed so quickly.  All I know is at the EW all-star game, they interviewed 2 WRs, a TE, and a G.  There are no IOL worth the #7 pick.  While a majority here seem to want that franchise LT,  Thomas has been slipping on the websites maintained by people who don't know squat--but there has to be a reason.  So without a T, and if Brown is off the board or not, will they pass on a top QB?  I know, Herbert sucks in your expert analysis, and I know, Walter sucks....everybody sucks.   But this is based on facts and it demonstrates the sentiment of a lot of experts after Mobile.

" 1/30/20: In 2019, Herbert completed 67 percent of his passes for 3,471 yards with 32 touchdowns and six interceptions. He scored four rushing touchdown too, but Oregon didn't run run him as much. The senior has all the physical tools to be a good NFL starter with a powerful arm, mobility and accuracy. When Herbert is given time, he is utterly deadly in his ability to carve up a defense. He is not a vocal leader, and some teams want their quarterback to be that kind of presence in the huddle, on the sideline, and in the locker room. Herbert had a solid week at the Senior Bowl, and team sources told me that he interviewed well there. "

So what is there not to like? The numbers are there---the tools are there.  Would we regret it one day for not taking a QB in the draft when our situation was so murky at the time?

5. If the Panthers were going to take a QB, would they say that the are not? Probably.  The stakes are high early in the draft.  Even Cincinnati is throwing out mixed signals. Why would the Panthers let everyone know what they plan to do? 

To me, Herbert is the only player that makes this point somewhat feasible.  You have a QB with all the tools--he just needs a clean pocket. He has a "powerful arm, mobility, and accuracy,"  If he check out during the interviews, what more is there?  A year to develop behind a veteran. 

So maybe we have discounted the possibility of taking a QB too soon.  No, I do not believe the Panthers have committed to Cam beyond a "We will keep you for 2020 if you are healthy," and I do not believe they would say that they do not like any of the QBs in this year's draft--and if they did---more reason to suspect they will.

The thing is, nobody knows.  This is not 2015, when the decision would be a no brainer.  There are so many unknowns--so many variables--and if they fall in love with Herbert, this could happen.

 

 

I dont want my franchise quarterback introverted

Link to comment
Share on other sites
kungfoodude Grand Master

kungfoodude

Posted
Posted
16 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

One read dink and dunker. Maybe he's capable of doing more, but that's what he did at Oregon.

By all accounts he is the most skilled QB in the draft. All the questions about him seem to be intangible based. I actually think he may end up being the best of this class.

 

That said....don't want. ESPECIALLY at 7.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
thefuzz Mentor

thefuzz

Posted
Posted
16 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

One read dink and dunker. Maybe he's capable of doing more, but that's what he did at Oregon.

Read the other day that was just their system, said that he would and should fare much better in a vertical passing system.

Also, this is lying time in the NFL and I don't believe a word coming from ANYONE'S mouth.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Growl Grand Master

Growl

Posted
Posted

I get that looking at the two rarified all star QB prospects in this class and taking the 3rd guy can be frustrating, but it's for that same reason he merits strong consideration

 

We have the 7th pick, not the 1st, nor are we going to have the 1st next season. In a normal draft class that doesn't feature two rarified, all star QB prospects, Herbert would be the 1st pick in the draft.

To get a QB who would go normally #1 overall at #7 (or 5 or whatever) is something you cant turn down, period, and would only do so if the team just genuinely hated Herbert as a prospect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • jb2288
      Josina Anderson: Panthers NOT trading Adam Thielen

      By jb2288 · Posted

      So answer the question. Why did Chark and Hurst have the same metrics (go look them up, I did... and one was actually worse in LA) with Justin Herbert? Why did Mingo have the same metrics with Dak? You're right, there is a common denominator, just not the one you're trying to make.  Why could DJ Moore get open with Bridgewater, Allen, Cam 2.0, Darnold, Baker, Williams, Bagent? I'll answer the question for you - because he is a good WR unlike Chark/Hurst/Mingo. 
    • jb2288
      Josina Anderson: Panthers NOT trading Adam Thielen

      By jb2288 · Posted

      I mean I just don't understand the argument. Baker and Sam both have been pro bowl QBs post their time here. And you just said yourself that is due to him having a damn good roster around him and they are well coached. You're even saying the bad baker is still there somewhere, but he is in a good organization with good roster and coaching that they are getting the best out of him. Why does Baker and Sam get all that benefit of the doubt but when it comes to Bryce it must be a BY9 problem, not an org or team problem?  Hell I got a guy below you arguing with me that Chark/Hurst/Mingo sucked because Bryce wouldn't throw them open. It's ridiculous how far the stretch goes. 
    • CRA
      Josina Anderson: Panthers NOT trading Adam Thielen

      By CRA · Posted

      Correct.  It’s really hard to get open in the NFL when opposing defenses gameplan and cheat coverage/routes on all your players because they know your QB can’t make certain throws/plays.   magically no one that comes to Carolina can get open or make plays with the ball in their hands…..it’s like there is one singular common dominator to it all.  BY makes playing defense way too easy.   NFL players are too good to allow one side to cheat coverage and not respect all the potential threats of a route  so you can dial up a great play.  But if corners and safeties just cheat coverage and know X and Y happening on route/threats….getting open gets hard when they just play it one way.  Getting open has a lot to do with the different threats a WR can pose on a given play.  
×
×
  • Create New...