Serious question: Jameis Winston or Bryce Young straight-up?

[Joe Bear]

6 hours ago, KillerKat said:

It would be smart to have Winston here to keep the pressure on Young and when he returns to the same ol Young, put Winston in for rest of the year.

But what about when Winston returns to the same ol Winston?

[CBDellinger]

Jameis for the sound bytes.

Bryce for the football. 

[Khyber53]

I'll take my chances with Bryce.

 

[Jon Snow]

You cannot be serious with this question? Young all day everyday.  You Winston fans are pathetic. 

[countryboi]

You can't win with Jameis. Yes, every once in a while, he throws for 500 yards, but he doesn't protect the ball and is always going to throw a ton of interceptions and put the team in a bad place.

this is not even a comparion to Bryce, I wouldnt want him on my roster. Jameis is fun to watch on someone else's team.

Edited December 3, 2024 by countryboi

[Davidson Deac II]

Interceptions are the worse thing a qb can do.  When an int is throw, it means either your team missed a chance to score or gave the other team an easy score (or sometimes both).  Given how many he throws, I can't imagine any circumstance where I would want Jameis as our starter.

Bryce is still an unknown and the unknown is better than the known Jameis.  

[Green-Ghost]

Based upon what I see so far without a doubt, Bryce Young.  I am very impressed with Jamis Winston.  I think he is a deep passer. I think he is talented and I think he is a terrific individual.  No question in my mind that his teammates rally around him.
 

I’m not sure why, but Jameis Winston has always had interception problems. 

[Panthering]

Bryce Young for sure, we know what Jameis is as this point. 

[Chaos]

My man tossed six TD's last night, of course it's Jameis.

 

Oh wait a minute.....

[JawnyBlaze]

Based on age, and the fact Bryce is trending up while Jameis is Jameis and will always be exactly what he is, it’s an easy decision: Bryce. If you had asked me three weeks ago, it would have been a different answer, but Bryce is showing capabilities he’d never shown any sign of before, so I’m opening up to the possibility of him actually being a legit franchise QB. 

Edited December 3, 2024 by JawnyBlaze

[Jay Roosevelt]

Bryce, just because there's still room to grow.

Jameis is what he's going to be at this point, which is probably underrated by most fans, but he's never going to be a true franchise QB long-term. He's basically the Vinny Testaverde of his generation.

Bryce may not end up being a franchise QB either, but he still has a chance to be. Especially with his recent performances. Even if he never plays better than he has the past month that still likely means he ends up having a better overall career than Jameis in the long run.

[Gapanthersfan]

Bryce version 2.0 has yet to give a game away or throw a WTF was that kind of ball. This is an unfathomable step up that I never thought possible. If he does nothing else going forward he has absolved himself from being the biggest draft bust in history. 

I will levy high praise in saying we have a guy we can win with, maybe. 2 weeks in a row he showed that he could deliver with the game on the line and that the moment wasn’t too big for him. Not everyone has that.

He airmailed an over 40 yard DIME to Tremble after avoiding a sack, rolling out and delivering with someone in his face… and he didn’t let up the entire game. 

So I don’t know who this kid is. I know who Winston is. I’ll ride with Bryce 

[CarolinaRideorDie]

I want Jameis's pregame and post game speeches, but Bryce when the game starts. Jameis is such a clown with his comments that I find it entertaining. Eat that W!!

[Mother Grabber]

scallops or crab legs?