Two really quick questions that you need to be honest about.

[CanadianCat]

1 minute ago, Raleigh PF said:

1. IF Cam is healthy, give him a 5-year, incentive laden deal, voidable after three years. It protects the Panthers long-term, but gives Cam upfront money if he produces quickly.

Thats not a bad option. I might want to see those options after the first year. 

[onmyown]

1. Why is this even a question? fug no.

2. If you truly want to play your career here, yes you do. If not, best for both parties to break up, it it’s not worth it for either.

[Silent Majority]

Shitty eager beavers lol

[thefuzz]

41 minutes ago, Jeremy Igo said:

Something to ponder.... 

 

1. If you are the Carolina Panthers do you give Cam Newton an extension?

 

2. If you are Cam Newton, do you step foot on a field under a 1 year contract?

 

 

1:  No, not under any circumstances at this time.  If he comes back next season, plays at a high level, has no issues with his feet or shoulder, then yes, after the season.

2:  Depends, but if you want another big contract you will likely need to do so.

[332nd]

No & no.

I do find it funny however that while as things stand this is a business decision by corporate, if the situation were reversed & Cam made a business decision to leave so he had a real chance at a ring or few... Many looking at this as a business decision for the Panthers' FO would call him every kind of traitor in the book.

[Harbingers]

1 hour ago, Jeremy Igo said:

Something to ponder.... 

 

1. If you are the Carolina Panthers do you give Cam Newton an extension?

 

2. If you are Cam Newton, do you step foot on a field under a 1 year contract?

1. Yes. They have maintained to play Cam when he is 100% healthy. It seems that this decision is mutual with Cam. If not Cam driven, which would rule that out.

2. See above. 

[CRA]

1 hour ago, Jeremy Igo said:

Something to ponder.... 

 

1. If you are the Carolina Panthers do you give Cam Newton an extension?

 

2. If you are Cam Newton, do you step foot on a field under a 1 year contract?

 

 

1.  Wouldn’t be smart from a business perspective 

2.   Same answer 

[Dunn]

The second question is the biggest one...being injured for basically the last 2 years, do you set this next year out to be your 'tryout' for the rest of the league for your final big payday?  Be it from the Panthers or another team after next year, he will potentially gain millions more if he plays next season here (given the opportunity) and show that he still has it to be a top 10 QB in the league.  On the other side, he could spiral down next year and potentially cost himself millions if gets hurt again or under performs...depends on how risky he wants to be. 

[SmokinwithWilly]

2 hours ago, 332nd said:

No & no.

I do find it funny however that while as things stand this is a business decision by corporate, if the situation were reversed & Cam made a business decision to leave so he had a real chance at a ring or few... Many looking at this as a business decision for the Panthers' FO would call him every kind of traitor in the book.

My question would be, which team is a Cam Newton away from a Super Bowl, especially considering a shoulder that's seen 2 surgeries and a lisfranc injury that isnt healing the way it was expected? The trade would have to be made in the offseason. I cant see any real Super Bowl contenders paying him starter money with such huge question marks. $30 million (bargain rate for what the huddle thinks of Cams skills) of cap space doesnt make sense for what has been for the last year and a half, damaged goods.

[Shocker]

There was talk of a hearty market for Cam before the deadline...yeah he wouldn’t pass the physical but you had to trade him there.  A good GM would have done so.

[raz]

no and no are the only intelligent answers from both parties

[TheSpecialJuan]

no to all three 

[panthers55]

6 hours ago, Bartin said:

1. No, unless he is willing to take some heavily incentive laden deal that has little to no guarantees which he would be dumb to take.

2. No, I would asked to be traded to a team that would give me an extension or to be released.

And if I were the Panthers I would trade him to an AFC team or keep him on his 1 year deal. I have the leverage to franchise tag him on a one year deal after that before I would have to consider an extension.

Cam isn't holding out, he already has 100 million and knows that will tarnish his image as an icon. He want to play and redeem himself. That will be Cam 2.0.

[j2sgam]

I know you’re not supposed to answer a question with a question, but....

1 -would Hurney 2.0 make another Jake mistake?

2 -do you want to show the world what you can do?