Top 10 worst qb rooms from CBS sports. Panthers number 9

[raleigh-panther]

I don’t think Canales and Morgan are as sold as they.need to say they are

bryce has to improve massively this year   

if he doesn’t, they will find another solution in 2027 

the stats on QBs of his stature over time aren’t great…we shall see

 

[cranky]

Not sure it makes sense given they have the Saints at 7 and Shough was actually pretty good last year

[Jackie Lee]

I don't think the Saints would trade Shough for Bryce lol. Don't get that ranking unless they are just using some shitty AI generated stat line that doesn't account for coming on strong late into the season once he got it figured out

[Chief Keek]

Not a surprise, Panthers should be ranked higher on that list. 

[Khaki Lackey]

8 hours ago, cranky said:

Not sure it makes sense given they have the Saints at 7 and Shough was actually pretty good last year

He's more likely to be their Kyle Allen than their Jake Delhomme.

[mrcompletely11]

11 minutes ago, Khaki Lackey said:

He's more likely to be their Kyle Allen than their Jake Delhomme.

Shough heating up at the end of the season is a bit worrisome though for sure

[strato]

54 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

Shough heating up at the end of the season is a bit worrisome though for sure

I think Moore is a good coach and they could have a very nice offense. I think Shough is in a good place to develop.  
 

I don’t like Atlanta’s QB situation but they have a lot of pieces especially if Pearce is allowed to play. 
 

Not sure about TB. 
 

I probably fear NO rising most out of the three. 
 

Edited May 6 by strato

[OldhamA]

2 hours ago, Chief Keek said:

Not a surprise, Panthers should be ranked higher on that list. 

Yeah I think 9 is very generous.

We don't have a quality starter. We know Grier can't play in this league and Pickett is poor.

It's the worst room on the roster by some distance.

[Mr Mojo Risin]

16 hours ago, frankw said:

In his 3rd season he barely edged out rookie Joe Flacco and 2nd year QB Christian Ponder.

Magnificent.

I mean you technically have to count his rookie year but in all honesty last year was more like year 2 for Young. His rookie year was such a sh*t show. None of his WRs from that year are in the NFL. Worst OG performances in NFL History and the coach got fired 11 games in. That's about as bad a scenario can get for a rookie QB

 

Josh Allen also had some serious doubters his first couple seasons. He only threw for 3,089 yards his 2nd season before making the jump. Young has to continue to improve and now that he's in the same system for a 3rd consecutive year he may keep showing improvement. And if he doesn't we should he in prime position to snag a top prospect next year

Edited May 6 by Mr Mojo Risin

[Jay Roosevelt]

I mean regardless of your view of Bryce our depth is terrible.

[strato]

Yeah I remember his first year. All the excuses. All ‘his’ people saying well Peyton Manning and whoever else had horrible rookie years.
 

As if he was Peyton Manning. Lol. So weak. No comparison ever to any bust ever, who I am pretty sure also had horrible rookie years.

Who else got 4 years after the kind of performance he has turned in? Anybody? Even three.. 

Forget the rooms, where is an honest QB power ranking list? Where does he sit there? How many rookies have come to bad teams and passed him on that list since he has been in the league? 
 

I swear if he doesn’t light it up this year and they don’t make a change I will be gone. Rather watch competitive knitting or something. 

 

[Carolina Cajun]

gonna be interesting to see if tyler shough was a flash or real.  in 9 games I admit he looked good, but I mean theres so many times when a qb came in lit it up for a bit and when the nfl figured them out they were busts.  Sam Howell just the other year, first 9 games of 2023 (same number Shough started) 2500 yards passing, 14 tds, 9 INTS (1 game had 4 though so honestly closer to 14-5), and now basically bouncing around as a backup or practice squadder.  Or Kyle Allen, or Matt Flynn.  These things happen, I just think a lot of people are way to high on him.

[RJK]

And people still defend Bryce like we can’t just look at the stats to see he’s all time bad 

[X-Clown]

17 hours ago, Sup said:

And he played a 17 game season.

But only 16 games