I’m trying to be positive on Bryce Young, but….

[LegioX]

That 4th and 1 play near goal line just sealed the deal for me that we need to move on from him. I’m still asking myself , why in the hell did he throw it away. Then when I see the replay and there was a wide open WR right infront of him,  it just solidifies the fact he does not have that “it” factor that comes along with the #1 pick. We need to move on after this year.

[Burnout189]

I'm not sure if he was actually throwing it away, or if it was just a completely horrible pass.

Regardless, it's inexcusable.

[X-Clown]

I don't play Madden anymore - but if they adjust ratings every week, they likely need to put his Awareness down to like a 5 out of 100 after that play and the other play where he couldn't decide whether or not to scramble or throw the ball and didn't really end up doing either one. 

[mc52beast]

I’m SMH and trying to figure out how Bryce goes from horrible to being top 10 the last 10 games of 2024 to being horrible again. You watch guys like Allen and Jackson play the way they do and I have to think that maybe Bryce just doesn’t have it. 

[AggieLean]

I tried. 
 

I’ve been down on him since he came to Carolina. Even when he was doing “well” at the end of last season, I still wasn’t sold because his numbers still didn’t pop out. He was still putting up game manager numbers. He had a really good game against ATL, and with that I told myself I’d be ok with him getting this season to start. 
 

After this past performance, I am squarely on the get rid of him train. All this inconsistency; I’m good on it. Ready to move on. I could see him playing decent down the stretch like he did last year, but the pressure will have been relieved by then. Ready to move on. 

Edited 18 hours ago by AggieLean

[LegioX]

2 minutes ago, mc52beast said:

I’m SMH and trying to figure out how Bryce goes from horrible to being top 10 the last 10 games of 2024 to being horrible again. You watch guys like Allen and Jackson play the way they do and I have to think that maybe Bryce just doesn’t have it. 

From what people have been saying, and I agree with them. Is that he was so good towards the end because there was no pressure to win. We were already out of the playoffs so everything was just icing on the cake. Now with a new season and “expectations” his mental fortitude sucks. He just doesnt have what it takes to make the tough and good decisions in critical moments of a game.

[tukafan21]

9 minutes ago, Burnout189 said:

I'm not sure if he was actually throwing it away, or if it was just a completely horrible pass.

Regardless, it's inexcusable.

If that wasn't a throw away but an actual pass attempt, then he should be cut right now, not tomorrow, not even just "today" but right this very second.

[Waldo]

Sanders was open but he wasn't tall enough to get it there with 2 big boys occupying space in between. It's not always that size matters but a 6'2"+ guy would have had a chance and Cam would have gunned it or ran for a first. 

Just admit the obvious that his limitations are pretty big and not just his size.

[La Pantera]

15 minutes ago, Burnout189 said:

I'm not sure if he was actually throwing it away, or if it was just a completely horrible pass.

Regardless, it's inexcusable.

This

[SOJA]

That fourth down play was one of the worst I've ever seen a QB make in game given the situation. Even worse than that PJ walker INT in the endzone years back against detroit

[bandu]

12 minutes ago, mc52beast said:

I’m SMH and trying to figure out how Bryce goes from horrible to being top 10 the last 10 games of 2024 to being horrible again. You watch guys like Allen and Jackson play the way they do and I have to think that maybe Bryce just doesn’t have it. 

so i have said this so many all these NFL Qbs are talented or they would not be in the NFL in the first place &sure play good at times 

consistency at Qb is what separates them all from the elite Qbs that play good week in & week out to Qbs like Bryce Young who plays bad way more than he plays good

& you can'ttruly  evaluate any player on what they do  just 25 % of the time & all at the same time conveniently ignore the other 75% of bad play .they are both equally important parts of the equation

...just saying 

[kungfoodude]

26 minutes ago, AggieLean said:

I tried. 
 

I’ve been down on him since he came to Carolina. Even when he was doing “well” at the end of last season, I still wasn’t sold because his numbers still didn’t pop out. He was still putting up game manager numbers. He had a really good game against ATL, and with that I told myself I’d be ok with him getting this season to start. 
 

After this past performance, I am squarely on the get rid of him train. All this inconsistency; I’m good on it. Ready to move on. I could see him playing decent down the stretch like he did last year, but the pressure will have been relieved by then. Ready to move on. 

100% agree. It was great to see the turnaround but this season was supposed to be his ascent to being an above average starting NFL QB, not a mid level game manager. At this point those games looked more like Kyle Allen's "Baby GOAT" run than anything else.

He has had enough chances. It's over. 

[Johnstonny]

5 minutes ago, kungfoodude said:

100% agree. It was great to see the turnaround but this season was supposed to be his ascent to being an above average starting NFL QB, not a mid level game manager. At this point those games looked more like Kyle Allen's "Baby GOAT" run than anything else.

He has had enough chances. It's over. 

Yea...how many times do you wanna jam the square peg in the round hole...guess as many times as Dipper tells you to.

[Bear Hands]

He clears left to give himself a clean look.  And Sanders is breaking to the left in stride, should easily be able to place it well.  Toss it, lead JT to only where he can grab it, it's a 13 yard throw. 

But then he suddenly stops, plants in a terribly awkward position, with his body parallel to the LOS, feet are facing in opposite directions angled outward.  It's egregious for a QB at a D2 level.  

start this at 7 m 15 s and put it on .50 playback speed: