Who wants Bryce to fail?

[DaveThePanther2008]

I don't want him to fail but it doesn't mean he's not. 2 decent drives in a game doesn't cut it in the NFL. The NYG gifted a win for us. 

I'm glad we won but we won because the NYG are worse than we are. 

If given the opportunity to move on from him I'd take it. 

[R0CKnR0LLA]

If we listened to a lot of people here, we'd end up in a situation exactly like the Giants giving a bum like Daniel Jones a $40 mill a year extension.

[Shotgun]

I didn’t want Young to fail…but he did anyway.

I didn’t want TMJ, Mingo, Corral, Grier and many others to fail either….but they did anyway.

[OldhamA]

6 hours ago, NAS said:

I think it’s the “we must find our QB” obsession that’s gotten us into trouble in the first place. We have to regain our culture and rebuild the roster. Take the wins and progress as they come and reevaluate in the offseason.  

Years of bad drafting has gotten us into trouble. Trading 5 premium players for Bryce Young was just the cherry on top - the death knell of the franchise. 

We're years away from digging ourselves out of that hole - but Legette, Sanders, Coker and Wallace are a very good start. 

[MechaZain]

He's been the worst quarterback in pro football for most of his career and game managed his way to two wins against bottom of the barrel teams. Let's be real here.

On the other end you have fans already planning the future around him because he's proven capable of rising to mediocrity for the win.

He's got a long way to go before we should even be thinking about him long term. The only reason this thread exists is because doing the bare minimum is progress for Bryce.

Edited November 11, 2024 by MechaZain

[kungfoodude]

15 hours ago, NAS said:

Just raise your hand here so you don’t have to ruin every positive thread when Panthers win. 

It’s one thing to be critical of Bryce when he deserves it but some of the hate on this board is just weird.  Stop trying to sugar coat it and admit you don’t want Bryce to do anything well because you have moved on forever and are looking to confirm your bias regarding his NFL future 

I wanted him benched too but every time he steps on the field I want him to succeed and do well. He still has a long ways to go but I think he can be a Brock Purdy type of QB with the right pieces around him.  And yes Purdy was not the top QB selected in the draft but 49ers gave up a haul for Trey Lance. You take the hand you’re dealt and don’t think about the sunk cost.

He isn't Brock Purdy in that example, he is Trey Lance.

[hepcat]

I genuinely don’t think there is a single Panthers fan who wants Bryce to fail. There’s a big difference between actively rooting for someone’s failure, and just observing the obvious. I didn’t personally think before the 2023 season “omg I hope Bryce fails I hate him” I was cautiously optimistic although admittedly skeptical because I had seen him play in college and he had a lot of red flags that seemed to be totally ignored in the draft process. But now? I don’t think he’s going to be the franchise QB for this team, he’s obviously too physically limited, but he might have a long career in the NFL as a backup and game manager. He’s just not the caliber of player who should have been taken #1 overall. He was wildly overhyped because he went to Alabama and the Panthers drank the proverbial kool ade. So long story short no, I don’t hope he fails, at this point I know he’s a failure relative to what the Panthers paid to get him. 

[Swaggasaurus]

17 hours ago, My Goodness My Guinness said:

Serious question for the box score folks? Did you actually watch the game or are you criticizing purely off 125 yards? An if you did watch the game, what would you say Bryce did poorly?

Missed Chuba to ice the game. Easy throw. Didn’t give Coker a chance on a deep ball. He just ain’t got the arm talent. Now…I do have one praise, his throw to David Moore in the red zone was perfect everything with really good coverage. 

[electro's horse]

3 hours ago, Swaggasaurus said:

Missed Chuba to ice the game. Easy throw. Didn’t give Coker a chance on a deep ball. He just ain’t got the arm talent. Now…I do have one praise, his throw to David Moore in the red zone was perfect everything with really good coverage. 

That was a high school level throw 

edit: oh you meant the one that got called back n/m

Edited November 11, 2024 by electro's horse

[Gapanthersfan]

I have always wanted Bryce to prove me wrong. I’ve never hoped for his demise. 
 

I said it in another thread: He is our very expensive bridge QB who has now made Dalton expendable.

He CAN at least throw some passes, and a good amount of his throws have been on point. My main interest is seeing our line and new pass catchers evolve. Coker, X, and Sanders have shown real talent and it can’t be allowed to get stale. 

Let him and Thielen walk. Plummer is backup QB. We now have the capital to sign Horn. 

[Brooklyn 3.0]

First time in thread. I don't need him to fail ... he'll do that on his own.

[strato]

1 hour ago, Gapanthersfan said:

I have always wanted Bryce to prove me wrong. I’ve never hoped for his demise. 
 

I said it in another thread: He is our very expensive bridge QB who has now made Dalton expendable.

He CAN at least throw some passes, and a good amount of his throws have been on point. My main interest is seeing our line and new pass catchers evolve. Coker, X, and Sanders have shown real talent and it can’t be allowed to get stale. 

Let him and Thielen walk. Plummer is backup QB. We now have the capital to sign Horn. 

I think we really need Andy to come in and remind everyone what it is supposed to look like. He's had his rest. And if he can't then we'd better find someone. Because Bryce as an NFL QB is down here and even a top 20 NFL QB is way up there. 

[TLGPanthersFan]

I don’t want him to fail. I want him to look decent enough to be able to trade him for more than a pittance. 

[tukafan21]

Wanting and knowing he has/will are two different things

Even the anti-Bryce people before the draft then got on board to hoping he’d be good once we made the pick

But this ship has sailed, he’s a bust for exactly what everyone saw before the draft, he doesn’t any the physical capabilities to be a starting NFL QB